NI Police Federation 'Appalled' By Hyde Park Deal

Terry Spence, the Chairman of the Police Federation for Northern Ireland has criticised the "grubby, secret deal" the UK Government agreed with "on-the-run" IRA members.

The comments come after it was revealed on Tuesday that a case against a Co Donegal man, accused of carrying out the 1982 Hyde Park bombing in London, had collapsed when a judge at the Old Bailey decided to throw out the case.

John Downey had been charged with the murders of four soldiers who had died in the attack. The 62-year-old was arrested at Gatwick Airport last year and was detained as his name appeared on the UK's most wanted list. Yesterday, however, it emerged that in 2007 - despite an outstanding warrant - that Mr Downey had been granted an immunity deal to help secure IRA decommissioning.

Commenting on the revelation, Mr Spence described the agreement as a "grubby, secret deal", adding: "This is sickening, and I know that it will re-open old wounds for scores of heartbroken families. None of us know of the existence of this Administrative Scheme or what it entailed or the number of OTRs involved.

"I am angry, disappointed and feel betrayed. Those involved in this skulduggery should hang their heads in shame. When were they going to tell us about it, and why did it take a mistake exposed at the Old Bailey to shine a spotlight on this sorry mess?"

In a statement, the families of those killed in the bombing said they were devastated by the development, while Chief Constable Matt Baggott said the police accepts "full responsibility" for the failures.

The agreement has also caused a row at Stormont among Northern Ireland's politicians.

Earlier on Wednesday, DUP MLA Peter Robinson described it as "an outrage and a dark day for justice", adding that justice should not "have a sell-by date". However, it has since been revealed that he has now threatened to quit his role as First Minister unless a judicial review is carried out into the matter.

In an interview with the BBC, Mr Robinson said he would not be prepared to remain in his post after he was "kept in the dark" regarding the issue.

UUP Justice spokesman Tom Elliott added that the immunity assurances handed out are "a disgrace", while Sinn Féin leader Gerry Adams TD welcomed court's decision, insisting that Downey "should never have been arrested and this has been vindicated by the court decision".

Also commenting on the controversy, Prime Minister David Cameron described the collapse of Mr Downey's case as a "dreadful mistake".

He admitted to MPs: "We should be absolutely clear. The man should never have received the letter that he received, Downey.

"It was a dreadful mistake and mistake that we now need to have a rapid factual review to make sure that this cannot happen again.

"But whatever happens we have to stick to the principle that we are a country and a government under the rule of law."

He added that it was "absolutely shocking" that the accused was not going to be tried for the Hyde Park bombing which killed four soldiers.

"I completely understand the depth of anger and concern that people will feel right across this country about the appalling events that happened in 1982 and the fact the person responsible is now not going to be appropriately tried," he continued.

In addition to Mr Downey, it was revealed that another 186 people received letters telling them they would not face arrest and prosecution for IRA crimes. Downey, had been convicted of IRA membership in the 1970s, but had denied murdering the soldiers and conspiring to cause an explosion.


Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

13 April 2011
Doubts Over 'Libyan IRA Atrocities Deal'
An NI pressure group acting for victims of the Troubles has welcomed news that strife-torn Libya has agreed a deal for victims to be compensated for multiple atrocities carried out by the IRA throughout the UK.
17 July 2014
OTR Letters 'Not An Amnesty'
'On the Run' letters sent to wanted republican terrorist suspects did not amount to an amnesty, a judge has found. Lady Justice Hallett has completed a review, ordered by Prime Minister David Cameron, on the so-called 'On the Run' letters.
22 May 2013
Man Charged Over Hyde Park Bombing
John Anthony Downey, from Co Donegal, has been charged with the murders of four soldiers in the IRA's Hyde Park bombing in London 31 years ago. Downey, 61, was arrested by police as he came off a plane at London's Gatwick Airport on Sunday. He is accused of being responsible for a car bomb in South Carriage Drive.
19 August 2013
DUP Maze Decision A 'Mistake' - McGuinness
Deputy First Minister Martin McGuinness has said a DUP decision not to support a peace and conflict resolution centre at the former Maze prison site is a "mistake". The centre was planned as part of a £300m redevelopment of the site, which had previously secured the support of the First Minister and DUP leader Peter Robinson.
29 January 2013
Justice Minister Says Blocking NCA Is 'A Mistake'
The National Crime Agency (NCA) has been blocked from operating in NI as it will in the UK. Sinn Féin and the SDLP have stopped a move to give the new policing agency, described as the ‘British FBI’, the powers to carry out police operations and recruit agents.
02 June 2011
Judge's Daughter Terror Killing 'Mistake'
The sister of an IRA murder victim - who was a judge's daughter - has spoken out after one of her killers went into print and called the death 'a tragic mistake.
29 March 2006
Plane lands at army base by mistake
A Ryanair passenger jet destined for Derry City Airport has landed at Ballykelly army base, six miles away by mistake. The plane is thought to have been the Ryanair 1425 service from Liverpool to Derry and it is believed to have had around 45 people, including crew, on board.
15 July 2003
Israeli radio says Belfast man's arrest was a 'mistake'
An Israeli radio station has reported that the arrest of a Northern Ireland man by security forces was a "mistake". The radio station, the Voice of Israel external service in Jerusalem, reported that the arrest of west Belfast man Seán O Muireagáin could be a "case of mistaken identity".
10 August 2001
Belfast lottery winners thank a lucky mistake
A syndicate of care workers from a north Belfast community centre were celebrating on Thursday after winning nearly £20,000 in The National lottery draw held last weekend after having mistakenly filled in the wrong numbers.
06 June 2013
Man In Court Over Hyde Park Bomb
A man is due to appear at the Old Bailey in London charged over the Hyde Park IRA bomb which killed four people. John Downey, 61, from Donegal, was arrested at Gatwick Airport last month over the 1982 attack.
12 May 2009
Judge Undecided On IRA Sources Case
A Belfast judge has said he is "minded" to give police permission to legally induce a reporter to reveal her dissident republican sources. However, Judge Tom Burgess insisted no decision will be made until both sides have stated their case.
26 June 2014
OTR Review Publication Date Announced
The publication date of the review into the administrative scheme for dealing with suspected On The Runs has been set for 17 July. Controversy over the scheme started following the collapse of a case against John Downey, a suspect in the 1982 IRA murder of four soldiers in Hyde Park.
05 October 2010
Real IRA Claims Derry Car Bombing
The dissident group, the Real IRA, has said it carried out this morning's terrorist bombing in Londonderry. The blast shook Derry which recently won the nomination as the UK City of Culture for 2013.
28 October 2009
'No Deal' On Libya Terror Compensation
Bereaved relatives of IRA victims seeking compensation from the Libyan government - which supplied arms and explosives to the terrorists - have scotched reports that a compensation deal has already been done with Colonel Gaddafi.
26 March 2008
Agreement Parties Take Stock
The DUP and Sinn Fein have each marked the first anniversary of the joint devolution deal with a review of the past year. The end of the IRA Army Council is in sight, claims DUP MP and Assembly Junior Minister Jeffrey Donaldson, who said that much progress had been made.