23/11/2001
Row erupts after fraudulent farmers escape prosecution
A row has arisen following the revelation that several farmers who fraudulently claimed for subsidies during the foot-and-mouth crisis are to escape prosecution thanks to a “technical deficiency” in the law.
Twelve cases of farmers falsely claiming subsidies for the slaughter of non-existent animals had been referred to the Director of Public Prosecutions. However, Agriculture Minister Brid Rodgers has announced that due to limitations in current legislation, the fraud prosecutions will not proceed.
The Minister went on to assure that she would be amending the regulations to cover such legal loopholes so that such instances of fraud could not reoccur.
She added: “I am determined that farmers who claim subsidies to which they are not entitled should be amenable to prosecution. I believe that this is the only fair approach and in the best interests of the vast majority of farmers who are entirely honest.”
Ian Paisley Jnr, a member of the Assembly’s Agricultural Committee, has called for Ms Rodgers to step down, on the grounds that her handling of the issue had been a failure that “makes the industry look bad in the eyes of the world”.
He added: “If she is really serious about taking on the sheep fraudsters she should pass these cases to the fraud squad or direct to the DPP instead of letting them off the hook.”
John Dallat SDLP MLA for East Derry and a member of the Agriculture Committee accused the DUP of a “sectarian witch hunt” against Mrs Rodgers. He said: “Any allegation that the Minister is at fault because of the failure of the British judicial system is made simply to score cheap sectarian points”.
However, offending farmers will still face financial penalties for discrepancies in their subsidy claims.
During the foot-and-mouth culls, 58 farmers in South Armagh were found to be claiming subsidy payments for more animals than they actually possessed – with some having no sheep at all. (CL)
Twelve cases of farmers falsely claiming subsidies for the slaughter of non-existent animals had been referred to the Director of Public Prosecutions. However, Agriculture Minister Brid Rodgers has announced that due to limitations in current legislation, the fraud prosecutions will not proceed.
The Minister went on to assure that she would be amending the regulations to cover such legal loopholes so that such instances of fraud could not reoccur.
She added: “I am determined that farmers who claim subsidies to which they are not entitled should be amenable to prosecution. I believe that this is the only fair approach and in the best interests of the vast majority of farmers who are entirely honest.”
Ian Paisley Jnr, a member of the Assembly’s Agricultural Committee, has called for Ms Rodgers to step down, on the grounds that her handling of the issue had been a failure that “makes the industry look bad in the eyes of the world”.
He added: “If she is really serious about taking on the sheep fraudsters she should pass these cases to the fraud squad or direct to the DPP instead of letting them off the hook.”
John Dallat SDLP MLA for East Derry and a member of the Agriculture Committee accused the DUP of a “sectarian witch hunt” against Mrs Rodgers. He said: “Any allegation that the Minister is at fault because of the failure of the British judicial system is made simply to score cheap sectarian points”.
However, offending farmers will still face financial penalties for discrepancies in their subsidy claims.
During the foot-and-mouth culls, 58 farmers in South Armagh were found to be claiming subsidy payments for more animals than they actually possessed – with some having no sheep at all. (CL)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
26 February 2024
PSNI Issues Warning Over Potential Holiday Fraud
People booking holidays have been urged to watch out for scammers, as new figures reveal that 89 reports of holiday fraud were made to the PSNI in 2023.
PSNI Issues Warning Over Potential Holiday Fraud
People booking holidays have been urged to watch out for scammers, as new figures reveal that 89 reports of holiday fraud were made to the PSNI in 2023.
12 February 2024
Over £713,000 Lost To 'Romance Fraud' In NI In Just 10 Months
More than £713,000 has been lost to "romance fraud" across Northern Ireland in the last 10 months, according to new PSNI figures. Ahead of Valentine's Day, the PSNI wants to raise awareness of this type of cruel and very personal fraud committed by criminals looking to swindle people looking for love.
Over £713,000 Lost To 'Romance Fraud' In NI In Just 10 Months
More than £713,000 has been lost to "romance fraud" across Northern Ireland in the last 10 months, according to new PSNI figures. Ahead of Valentine's Day, the PSNI wants to raise awareness of this type of cruel and very personal fraud committed by criminals looking to swindle people looking for love.
17 January 2024
£23.1m Lost To Fraud In NI In Last 13 Months
A total of £23.1 million has been lost to financial fraud in Northern Ireland in the last 13 months, according to the latest figures from Action Fraud. In the period before December 2022 and January 15 2024, the PSNI received 5,412 reports of fraud.
£23.1m Lost To Fraud In NI In Last 13 Months
A total of £23.1 million has been lost to financial fraud in Northern Ireland in the last 13 months, according to the latest figures from Action Fraud. In the period before December 2022 and January 15 2024, the PSNI received 5,412 reports of fraud.
08 March 2024
Other News In Brief
Man Jailed For Illegal Moneylending Operation In Larne The PSNI have welcomed the sentencing of a 45-year-old man at Belfast Crown Court for illegal moneylending offences in the Larne area. Steven Spence from the Larne area was convicted of carrying on a regulated activity in breach of general prohibition and acquiring criminal property.
Other News In Brief
Man Jailed For Illegal Moneylending Operation In Larne The PSNI have welcomed the sentencing of a 45-year-old man at Belfast Crown Court for illegal moneylending offences in the Larne area. Steven Spence from the Larne area was convicted of carrying on a regulated activity in breach of general prohibition and acquiring criminal property.
29 January 2024
Man Due In Court Charged With Kevin Conway Murder
A 27-year-old man is due to appear before Belfast Magistrates' Court today, Monday, 29 January, charged with the murder of Kevin Conway. The man was arrested in west Belfast on 09 January, by detectives investigating the murder. Police have said that as is usual procedure, the charge will be reviewed by the Public Prosecution Service.
Man Due In Court Charged With Kevin Conway Murder
A 27-year-old man is due to appear before Belfast Magistrates' Court today, Monday, 29 January, charged with the murder of Kevin Conway. The man was arrested in west Belfast on 09 January, by detectives investigating the murder. Police have said that as is usual procedure, the charge will be reviewed by the Public Prosecution Service.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:Cloudy with further outbreaks of rain this morning, heavy at times, especially over north Antrim. Becoming drier and brighter this afternoon with sunny spells and a few showers. Winds becoming light. Maximum temperature 9 °C.Tonight:Further showers this evening, some heavy, especially in the east, dying out early tonight. Then mainly dry with clear periods developing, leading to a touch of frost and icy patches. Minimum temperature -1 °C.