05/11/2001

High Court dismisses DUP's case against NI Secretary of State

A High Court judge has dismissed the DUP's legal action taken against the Secretary of State’s decision not to call fresh elections to the Northern Ireland Assembly.

The case brought by the deputy leader of the anti-Agreement Democratic Unionist Party, Peter Robinson was heard by Mr Justice Kerr in the High Court on Monday November 5.

The DUP’s legal challenge was mounted because they deemed last Friday’s unsuccessful attempt to re-elect David Trimble as head of Assembly’s Executive and Mark Durkan as deputy first minister ahead of the Saturday deadline and the subsequent decision by Dr Reid not to call fresh elections or call a suspension of the Assembly to be unlawful.

However, lawyers acting on behalf of Dr Reid said that the Secretary of State enjoyed a degree of latitude over the time he could take before proposing a date for elections.

The judge said it was entirely unsurprising that the Secretary of State wished for a period of reflection before setting a date.

Speaking after the ruling on Monday November 5, Secretary of State John Reid said: “I am pleased but not surprised that the court has rejected the DUP’s legal challenge today. I am confident that I have acted at all times within the law.”

Speaking at Stormont, Mr Trimble said: “The DUP are there playing games, pulling stunts, engaging in personal abuse rather than trying to improve the situation in this society.”

However, DUP leader Ian Paisley said: “In the last 24 hours the Secretary of State has performed a seismic U-turn on his obligation to propose a date for an election today he conceded that he is under an obligation to propose a date for elections and will consult the parties and then set a date. Now that the Secretary of State has accepted his obligations it is time for him to set a date for an early election and let the people decide.”

The court’s decision removes any doubt that a vote can now go ahead on Tuesday for a first and deputy first minister. (AMcE)

Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

17 September 2019
Teen Charged In Connection With Belfast Disorder
A 15-year-old boy has been charged with possessing a blade or point in a public place in connection with disorder in Belfast. The boy is due to appear at the Belfast Youth Court next month on Friday 11 October.
04 September 2019
Pair Sentenced For Benefit Fraud
A man and woman have been handed suspended sentences after they were convicted of benefit fraud. The pair were dealt with at Belfast Magistrates' Court on Tuesday 03 September after each claiming payments they were not entitled to.
02 July 2019
Teen Jailed For Sexual Offences
A teenage male has been jailed for a series of sexual offences. The youth was given a sentence of three years at Newry Youth Court on Monday 01 July- 12 months to be spent in custody and two years on licence. He will also be on the sex offender's register for life.
18 September 2019
Soldier F Case Heard In Court
The prosecution case of a former British soldier accused of two murders on Bloody Sunday is due to begin in court. Soldier F, who is now in his 60s, is not expected to appear at L'Derry Magistrates' Court on Wednesday but will be represented by his legal team.
13 September 2019
Suspect Due In Court Over Car-Bomb Murder Bid
A 38-year-old man is due in court for a number of offences, including attempted murder, after an under car-bomb was planted in a ploy to kill a serving PSNI officer. The suspect was detained in Belleek, Co Fermanagh on Wednesday morning, 11 September.