Omagh Bombing: ECHR Rejects 'Unfair Trial' Claims

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has declared that a trial of two Irish republicans found liable for the Omagh bomb was not unfair.

29 were killed in one of the worst atrocities of the Troubles in 1998.

Liam Campbell and Michael McKevitt were two of four men found liable. The civil case was brought by families of the victims.

The relatives were awarded £1.6million in damages.

However, Campbell and McKevitt both took their case to Europe and said that a civil trial in Belfast had been unfair.

They claimed that due to the severity of the charges the court should have applied criminal, rather than civil, standards of proof.

They also claimed claimed that the admission of the evidence of an FBI agent who had not been made available in court for questioning was unfair.

The EHRC rejected the claims.

It found that a criminal standard of proof was not necessary because the proceedings had been for a civil claim for damages and there was no criminal charge.
News Image
In relation to the evidence of the absent FBI agent, the Court found that the judge had fully considered the need for appropriate safeguards given the witness's absence; that the defendants had had an adequate opportunity to challenge the agent’s evidence with their own; and that the judge had had due regard to the appropriate considerations when deciding what weight he could attach to the evidence of an absent witness.

McKevitt is currently behind bards in Portlaoise and Campbell is in Maghaberry Prison.

Ulster Unionist MEP Jim Nicholson said: "The Omagh bomb was an horrific and despicable atrocity. 18 years after the event we are still waiting for the terrorists who caused the devastating explosion in 1998 that killed 29 people and injured hundreds more, to be brought to justice.

"With regard to this case, the applicants had complained to the European Court of Human Rights that the civil claim brought against them and others, by many of the Omagh families, had been unfair. The Court has unanimously declared the applications inadmissible.

"We must never forget that it is the Omagh families and their loved ones who are the real victims. It is they who have had their human rights violated and who have been fighting for justice since that dreadful day in August 1998. If this decision by the European Court of Human Rights helps the Omagh families in their pursuit of truth and justice, then it is to be welcomed."

Pic: PA


Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

15 November 2021
Five Arrested In Connection With Human Rights Abuse
A woman and four men has been arrested by officers from the Paramilitary Crime Task Force investigating a range of human rights abuse and violent criminal activity linked to the North Antrim UDA.
12 November 2021
Southern Trust Called To Restore Home Care Services To Craigavon Families
The Southern Trust is being urged to restore home care services to families in the Criagavon area. Sinn Féin MLA John O'Dowd has written to the Southern Trust following the withdrawal of home care provider Quality Care Services from the area. He said: "Families are seeking answers on care for their loved ones in the days and weeks ahead.
22 January 2003
Omagh bomb families lodge £10m damages claim
Lawyers acting for the families of the Omagh bomb victims have lodged documents in the Dublin High Court today indicating that the sum of damages sought will top £10 million. The civil action is expected to be heard in Belfast against Michael McKevitt, 51, Liam Campbell, 38, Colm Murphy, 51, Seamus McKenna, 49, and 33-year-old Seamus Daly.
11 August 2003
Omagh victims should be granted legal aid, says Paisley
The DUP leader, Dr Ian Paisley, has called on the government to provide full legal aid to victims of the Omagh bombing to finance their civil action against those suspected of being responsible for the atrocity.
25 July 2002
Omagh funding opens door to court action
Relatives of the 29 people killed in the Omagh bomb are set to mount a civil suit against the alleged perpetrators after a public appeal netted the group enough money to proceed with the action. The Omagh Victims' Legal Trust raised their £1 million funding target only days before the deadline for legal proceedings runs through.