Fourth report on baton round alternatives published

The fourth report by the NIO on finding an alternative to the baton round, one of the recommendations of the Patton Commission on Policing, has been published today.

The report, entitled 'A research programme into alternative policing approaches towards the management of conflict' details two approaches that are considered to offer potential as alternatives to the plastic baton round.

One possible alternative is the 'Attenuating Energy Projectile' and the other is a 'Discriminating Irritant Projectile'.

Security Minister Jane Kennedy said the report set out the Government's position in relation to "the research programme to find an acceptable, effective and less potentially lethal alternative to the baton round, describing in detail two approaches that have real potential as alternatives".

The Minister said: "Very good progress has been made in developing these two alternative projectiles, in line with Patten's criteria and these are currently at the prototype stage."

The Attenuating Energy Projectile, is a result of research following up the previously published evaluation of the current baton round by the independent medical advisers. This approach is designed to reduce the peak force, thereby achieving a similar effect to the existing baton round, but more safely. Development work is continuing and subject to further testing, the government expects that this alternative will be deployed by summer 2005.

Other work continues on different technology, including the Discriminating Irritant Projectile. This would incapacitate a violent individual through delivery of irritant to their upper body, at a distance. An entirely new system for the UK this would take an additional year to develop.

This report also looks at other "public order equipment" including the introduction of new water cannon for the PSNI.

Commenting today, the Chairman of the Policing Board, Professor Desmond Rea, confirmed that the Board would be giving the findings in the fourth report "careful consideration"

Sinn Féin policing spokesperson Gerry Kelly responded by demanding that plastic bullets should be removed from operational use immediately.

Mr Kelly said: “The British government committed themselves to the removal of plastic bullets from operational use. These are lethal weapons that have killed 17 people. They should not be in use.

“The consideration of alternatives is no excuse to delay any further the removal of lethal plastic bullets. The PSNI and British Army have used and misused plastic bullets to kill and maim men, women and children. Any alternatives must be non-lethal.”


Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

08 April 2003
Latest baton rounds branded 'more dangerous'
A new report on baton rounds published by the Human Rights Commission has raised serious concerns about the safety of plastic bullets.
25 March 2005
PSNI to get new plastic baton round
The PSNI is to adopt a new plastic baton round following backing from the Northern Ireland Policing Board.
07 April 2005
Plastic baton round adopted despite SDLP objections
The Northern Ireland Policing Board has said it is to follow through with recommendations for a new plastic baton round.
05 February 2004
Conference to discuss alternatives to baton rounds
A major International Law Enforcement conference has discussed the progress towards finding an alternative to the baton round. Representatives from police services and other law enforcement agencies across the world attended today's conference in London which had Article 2 of the UN Basic Principles on the use of Force and Firearms as its theme.
20 December 2002
No alternative to baton rounds says report
There is no alternative to baton rounds when it comes to crowd control, according to a government report. The Steering Group for the phase 3 report on baton rounds has stated that that there is "still no off-the-shelf, commercially available, effective and acceptable alternative to the baton round at this time".