31/10/2018

'No One Protected' In Murder Probe - Ombudsman

Police carried out a "comprehensive" investigation into the murder of Robert McCartney in Belfast, according to a watchdog report.

The Police Ombudsman Dr Michael Maguire emphasised that nobody was protected in the murder probe in January 2005.

Mr McCartney, 33, was fatally beaten and stabbed outside Magennis's bar in Belfast, near his home. IRA members were suspected of involvement in the killing.

The report said: "The police investigation of events that night was complex, with what can best be described as some unique obstacles, including a reluctance by some witnesses to give evidence and concerns about the credibility of others."

Dr Maguire added that while the family of Mr McCartney may feel they have been failed by the criminal justice system, there is no evidence that police played any part in that failure.
News Image
The Ombudsman's Office received a series of complaints about how police conducted the investigation in 2005, including allegations that those responsible may have been informants who were protected from justice.

"A lot of the public discussion on what happened has focused on events in Magennis's bar, although Robert and his friends were subjected to a brutal attack in a busy street close to city centre.

"The McCartney family may have comforted themselves with the thought that the very public nature of the attack would in itself have helped find and convict those responsible.

"I can only begin to understand their frustration when this did not happen."

The watchdog report found that the alleged delay in police arriving at the bar was not due to inefficiency, and investigators established that the equivalent of three industrial bins of material were recovered from the scenes and extensive DNA testing was carried out on blood matter.

It was also confirmed that police went to "considerable lengths" to identify everyone who had been in Magennis's bar before the murder, and extensive interviews and searches were carried out to find the origins and whereabouts of the knife used.



(JG/CM)

Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

04 May 2021
Man Charged With Over 60 Offences After Gun Incident
A man, aged 32, has been charged with over 60 offences following a gun incident in north Belfast. Two shots were fired in the Silverstream Road/ Manor Street area of the city at around 10.30am on Sunday, 02 May. There were no reports of any injuries.
06 May 2021
'Investigative Failures' By Police Found Over Four Deaths
Significant operational and investigative failures by the police over the deaths of four people during severe disorder in Belfast in August 1969 have been found, according to the Police Ombudsman.
22 January 2007
Report catalogues murder prosecution failures
The Police Ombudsman's inquiry into to role of paid police informers in 15 loyalist paramilitary murders has catalogued a list of failures to bring prosecutions due to missing and obstructed evidence due to Special Branch involvement in the investigations.
20 February 2014
Man Arrested In Bangor Shooting Investigation
A man has been arrested by detectives investigating the attempted murder of two men in Bangor. The male victims, aged 24 and 33, were shot as they sat in a car in the Eastway area of the Whitehill estate at about 00:45 on 10 February. UTV has reported that the UVF are thought to have been behind the attack.
23 June 2016
Police Officers Disciplined For Failing To Tell Doctor About Woman's Head Injuries
Two police officers have been disciplined after they failed to let their colleagues and a police doctor know that a woman had sustained a head injury, a Police Ombudsman investigation has concluded. The woman died from bleeding to the brain on 24 February 2014, the day after she suffered the injury.