United Ireland The 'Only Winning Scenario' After Brexit - Report

The "only winning scenario" for Northern Ireland after Brexit is a United Ireland, a report has suggested.

The Costs of Non-Unification- Brexit and the Unification of Ireland report predicts that both Northern Ireland and the Irish Republic will suffer economically once the UK leaves the European Union.

Three potential outcomes are laid out in the study: a hard Brexit, in which all of the UK leaves the single market and the customs union, Northern Ireland remaining within the single market and customs union, and the unification of Ireland.

It found that a hard Brexit would reduce Northern Ireland's GDP by 10.1 billion euro (£8.8 billion) from 2021-25.

The second option, remaining in the single market and customs union, would prompt a GDP dip of 3.8 billion euro (£3.3 billion), according to the report.

However, a united Ireland would see Northern Ireland increase its GDP.

"If political actors nevertheless prefer a hard Brexit, or if they are willing to accept a hard Brexit for overarching political reasons, then they accept willingly high negative economic costs," the study details.

It was carried out by Canadian firm KLC Consultants for US-based Irish American organisation KRB Inc.

It comes as negotiations intensify over whether the UK and EU will agree a backstop plan, resulting in Northern Ireland remaining within the customs union after Brexit. The issue has stalled recent talks.
News Image
Presenting the report at the Europa Hotel in Belfast on Wednesday 07 November, one of the authors, Dr Kurt Hubner, said the Brexit referendum has created enormous change.

"Since the referendum the whole picture has changed enormously, the macro economic situation has shifted.

"We already have huge opportunity costs and now with the way we tried to develop those scenarios, it is surprising that the unification one is the only one that would produce positive effects.

"Whereas with a hard Brexit the losses are already piling up."

Sinn Fein Vice President Michelle O'Neill and Ulster Unionist Steve Aiken were among those who attended the launch.

Mrs O'Neill described it as "compelling evidence that could not be ignored".

"This report, and particular economic modelling, exposes the hard evidence that reunification would provide a massive boost to the entire island," she said.

"In the words of the report, unification is the only option with positive net effects."

Mr Aiken, however, said he was skeptical of the new research.

"A future they say of about 10 billion euro over the space of a decade is absolutely miniscule and is well within the margin for error," the South Antrim MLA said.

"I can only presume when they continue to put data into the model, they will suddenly realise something we have all known all along- that unification is not an answer and would be a net detriment to Northern Ireland."


Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

13 June 2005
The 2005 Birthday Honours List for Northern Ireland
The full list of recipients of honours in the 2005 Birthday Honours list for Northern Ireland is as follows: Knighthood: Mr Hugh Orde OBE, Chief Constable, Police Service of Northern Ireland - for services to Northern Ireland. CBE: Mr Robert David Stewart Campbell, Belfast - For Political and public service.
25 August 2010
NAMA Applauded At Stormont
There has been high-level support expressed for the work of the Irish Republic's National Asset Management Agency, (NAMA) and its impact on NI finances.
24 April 2006
DUP attend British-Irish Inter Parliamentary talks
The DUP are to attend a meeting of the British-Irish Inter-Parliamentary Body today in Killarney, after boycotting the body for the past 16-years.
24 July 2002
NI aerospace industry represented at Farnborough
“Northern Ireland aerospace companies must strengthen their knowledge base and overall competitiveness with greater focus on innovation through R&D projects and technology transfer from collaboration with overseas partners,” said Sir Reg Empey, Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Investment.
29 February 2012
NI In Danger Of Lurching Back Into The Past
Northern Ireland seems in danger of lurching back into the past according to a new study. The Northern Ireland Monitoring report also stated "no new political party has emerged" since the Good Friday Agreement 14 years ago.
27 July 2009
'Deep Regret' Over NI Checkpoint Death
The British government has expressed its "deep regret" at the death of Aiden McAnespie, who was shot at an army checkpoint in Co Tyrone, 21 years ago. Mr McAnespie, 24, was shot by a soldier as he walked through a border checkpoint at Aughnacloy in February 1998.
10 October 2007
Finances To Be Challenging At Assembly
Stormont Finance Minister Peter Robinson has warned that the chancellor's Pre-Budget report demonstrates slowing public finances and that difficult decisions will have to be made at the Assembly to meet substantial challenges in Ulster's public services.
27 June 2006
NI sex offenders increase by 15%
A new report published today has revealed that the number of dangerous sex offenders living in Northern Ireland has increased by 15%, bringing the total living in the province to almost 700.
16 January 2004
Government to clampdown on sick day increase
Local Government ministers have said that they are committed to tackling increasing levels of sickness absence in the Northern Ireland Civil Service and other government departments.
18 July 2003
Prison Service meets majority of yearly targets
The annual report of the Northern Ireland Prison Service has revealed that the Service met the majority of its targets over the past year. The report, which was released on Thursday, showed that for the year 2002/03 the Service met 8 out of its 11 key targets including those covering security, safety and expenditure.
11 October 2002
Survey reveals majority would not report a crime
The Northern Ireland Office today released the findings of an organised crime bulletin which revealed that more than half of those surveyed would not report a crime to the police.
29 May 2012
Access To Republic Of Ireland Digital TV Channels Confirmed For Northern Ireland
TV viewers in Northern Ireland will be able to watch TG4 and RTÉ One and Two on Freeview following digital TV switchover, the UK Government confirmed today.
20 February 2007
Northern Ireland goes to Washington
Washington DC is to experience Northern Ireland’s arts and culture during a four month programme to promote arts, business, education, food and tourism.

 Around 250 local people will be in Washington taking part in the Rediscover Northern Ireland programme and the Smithsonian Institution’s Folklife Festival.
29 October 2014
NI's Food And Drink Industry Congratulated
Northern Ireland's food and drink industry has been celebrated at an event organised by Invest Northern Ireland and the Northern Ireland Tourist Board. The event celebrated the achievements of companies in the Great Taste Awards, the Irish National Food Awards and the Irish Quality Food and Drink Awards.
03 April 2014
HBO Joins Tourism Ireland
HBO has joined forces with Tourism Ireland to launch a new campaign seeking to promote Northern Ireland through its fantasy drama Game Of Thrones.