20/02/2019
Petition Of Concern Reforms Vital To Break Political Deadlock - Alliance
Reforming the Petition of Concern (PoC) mechanism is the key to unlocking devolved government at Stormont, according to the Alliance Party.
The cross-community veto was used in the Northern Ireland Assembly as a way of preventing discrimination, but became the subject of much criticism after it was repeatedly use to block decision-making before the institutions collapsed early in 2017.
Alliance MLA Paula Bradshaw said the mechanism is important in protecting minority rights, but in practice was often used to block the delivery of parliament decisions and frustrate progress on decisive issues.
Indeed, it has been used on a range of matters, from same-sex marriage to welfare reform legislation, over 100 times between 2011 and 2016.
The PoC requires the signatures of 30 politicians. Once secured, an assembly vote can only pass if it is supported by a weighted majority, 60% of the MLA's voting, with 40% of those being designated as nationalist or unionist.
In practice, larger parties can block decisions based on the strength of their numbers alone.
Ms Bradshaw, who represents south Belfast, said: "Alliance put proposals on the table to reform the POC almost two years ago. It was designed to protect minorities. Instead, it has been used to frustrate progress, stop the Assembly from holding Ministers to account, and block the delivery of rights and equality. Reforming it is key to opening progression on a whole range of rights issues.
"It is crucial when the Assembly returns, the POC would be no longer used to do what it has before. Instead, any future POC would be strictly limited to matters involving changes to the Assembly or constitutional matters, specific issues around identity and culture, or issues relating to the past such as legacy, victims and paramilitarism.
"Reform of the POC is a necessary measure to make any future Assembly sustainable, as well as see our society achieve equality on a number of issues. We need to get it back to its original intent and away from what it has become, which is used and abused to protect parties' selfish interests."
Under Alliance's proposals, every POC would need to be signed and dated, excluding pre-signed forms, and clearly state why the mechanism needs to be used. Parties would also be required to satisfy a member of a legal panel on how it meets the criteria.
(JG/MH)
The cross-community veto was used in the Northern Ireland Assembly as a way of preventing discrimination, but became the subject of much criticism after it was repeatedly use to block decision-making before the institutions collapsed early in 2017.
Alliance MLA Paula Bradshaw said the mechanism is important in protecting minority rights, but in practice was often used to block the delivery of parliament decisions and frustrate progress on decisive issues.
Indeed, it has been used on a range of matters, from same-sex marriage to welfare reform legislation, over 100 times between 2011 and 2016.
The PoC requires the signatures of 30 politicians. Once secured, an assembly vote can only pass if it is supported by a weighted majority, 60% of the MLA's voting, with 40% of those being designated as nationalist or unionist.
In practice, larger parties can block decisions based on the strength of their numbers alone.
Ms Bradshaw, who represents south Belfast, said: "Alliance put proposals on the table to reform the POC almost two years ago. It was designed to protect minorities. Instead, it has been used to frustrate progress, stop the Assembly from holding Ministers to account, and block the delivery of rights and equality. Reforming it is key to opening progression on a whole range of rights issues.
"It is crucial when the Assembly returns, the POC would be no longer used to do what it has before. Instead, any future POC would be strictly limited to matters involving changes to the Assembly or constitutional matters, specific issues around identity and culture, or issues relating to the past such as legacy, victims and paramilitarism.
"Reform of the POC is a necessary measure to make any future Assembly sustainable, as well as see our society achieve equality on a number of issues. We need to get it back to its original intent and away from what it has become, which is used and abused to protect parties' selfish interests."
Under Alliance's proposals, every POC would need to be signed and dated, excluding pre-signed forms, and clearly state why the mechanism needs to be used. Parties would also be required to satisfy a member of a legal panel on how it meets the criteria.
(JG/MH)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
05 March 2024
Chief Constable Committed To Addressing Issues In Sean Browne Investigation
The PSNI Chief Constable has said that he is committed to working with the family of Sean Browne and others impacted by the disclosure limitations of the coronial process. Chief Constable, Jon Boutcher, made the commitment as he acknowledged the comments of the Coroner on the murder of GAA Official, Sean Browne, in 1997.
Chief Constable Committed To Addressing Issues In Sean Browne Investigation
The PSNI Chief Constable has said that he is committed to working with the family of Sean Browne and others impacted by the disclosure limitations of the coronial process. Chief Constable, Jon Boutcher, made the commitment as he acknowledged the comments of the Coroner on the murder of GAA Official, Sean Browne, in 1997.
26 February 2024
PSNI Issues Warning Over Potential Holiday Fraud
People booking holidays have been urged to watch out for scammers, as new figures reveal that 89 reports of holiday fraud were made to the PSNI in 2023.
PSNI Issues Warning Over Potential Holiday Fraud
People booking holidays have been urged to watch out for scammers, as new figures reveal that 89 reports of holiday fraud were made to the PSNI in 2023.
08 February 2024
DAERA Minister To Prioritise Animal Welfare Issues
New Department for Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) Minister, Andrew Muir, has said that animal welfare issues will be among his top priorities. The Minister was speaking during a visit to the offices of the USPCA in Newry where he met with staff and volunteers during which a range of animal health issues were discussed.
DAERA Minister To Prioritise Animal Welfare Issues
New Department for Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) Minister, Andrew Muir, has said that animal welfare issues will be among his top priorities. The Minister was speaking during a visit to the offices of the USPCA in Newry where he met with staff and volunteers during which a range of animal health issues were discussed.
21 February 2024
Waiting Lists Cannot Be Tackled In Isolation – Swann
Hospital waiting lists cannot be tackled in isolation from other fundamental issues facing health and social care, Health Minister Robin Swann has said. Speaking in the Assembly on Tuesday, 20 February, the Minister warned that "piecemeal interventions" alone will not be sufficient.
Waiting Lists Cannot Be Tackled In Isolation – Swann
Hospital waiting lists cannot be tackled in isolation from other fundamental issues facing health and social care, Health Minister Robin Swann has said. Speaking in the Assembly on Tuesday, 20 February, the Minister warned that "piecemeal interventions" alone will not be sufficient.
16 February 2024
Collaboration Essential For Farming And Environment Sectors
Collaboration is essential to delivering real environmental improvement whilst ensuring economic resilience in the agriculture sector, DAERA Minister, Andrew Muir, has said.
Collaboration Essential For Farming And Environment Sectors
Collaboration is essential to delivering real environmental improvement whilst ensuring economic resilience in the agriculture sector, DAERA Minister, Andrew Muir, has said.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:Mainly dry this morning with sunny spells then scattered showers breaking out this afternoon. A chilly start then feeling warmer in afternoon sunshine. Light southerly winds. Maximum temperature 11 °C.Tonight:Any showers at first soon dying out. Then dry overnight with clear periods and turning chilly with a touch of frost later tonight. Minimum temperature 1 °C.