09/05/2019
Arts Council Chief Executive Settles Age Discrimination Case For £12k
The Arts Council of Northern Ireland has settled an age discrimination and victimisation case with its Chief Executive Roisin McDonough for £12,000.
Ms McDonough brought the case, with the support of the Equality Commission for Northern Ireland (ECNI), after speculation about her retirement plans became apparent.
The Arts Council, which she has been Chief Executive of since October 2000, settled the matter without admission of liability. In January 2017, Ms McDonough applied to the Chairperson of the Arts Council for flexible retirement. She wished to reduce her working hours from five days to four days per week from 01 April 2017, having previously indicated that this might be for a limited time as she was considering retirement.
Over the next period, no decision was taken on her request and she alleged that she was asked instead, on a number of occasions, about her plans to fully retire and if she had decided on a final retirement date. She became aware of speculation within the workplace about when she would retire and who might apply for the post. Ms McDonough considered this inappropriate and undermining to her position as Chief Executive.
Due to the failure to progress her request for flexible retirement, Ms McDonough commenced an internal grievance procedure and subsequently lodged proceedings claiming discrimination under the Employment Equality (Age) Regulations (NI) 2006. An internal panel upheld her grievance complaint and recommended that her request be processed immediately. She commenced flexible retirement in September 2017.
Ms McDonough said: "I want to thank the Equality Commission for supporting me in my case. It's important if people feel their rights at work are not being upheld that they know they can seek independent support and they will be listened to. Public sector workers, at whatever level they are employed in an organisation, are entitled to the same rights as anyone else.
"I believed my flexible retirement request was in line with the organisation's Human Resources policies. I was disappointed that my request was not being progressed and felt under pressure to provide a definite date for retirement. I believed that this was inappropriate and that any decision on my retirement should be mine and mine alone."
Anne McKernan, Head of Legal Services at the ECNI said: "In settling the case, the Arts Council has acknowledged and regrets the hurt and injury to feelings experienced by Roisin McDonough. It has reaffirmed its commitment to the principle of equality of opportunity in employment and will liaise with the Commission and review its policies and procedures concerning age. It will ensure that these policies and procedures relating to age are communicated to all staff and to Board members and that appropriate training is provided.
"Since the introduction of the Age Discrimination Regulation in 2006 and the abolition of the default retirement age in 2011, many people choose to work longer and many employers offer schemes such as flexible retirement. This helps our workplace retain talented and experienced members of staff for longer periods, which must be welcomed," concluded Anne McKernan.
(JG/CM)
Ms McDonough brought the case, with the support of the Equality Commission for Northern Ireland (ECNI), after speculation about her retirement plans became apparent.
The Arts Council, which she has been Chief Executive of since October 2000, settled the matter without admission of liability. In January 2017, Ms McDonough applied to the Chairperson of the Arts Council for flexible retirement. She wished to reduce her working hours from five days to four days per week from 01 April 2017, having previously indicated that this might be for a limited time as she was considering retirement.
Over the next period, no decision was taken on her request and she alleged that she was asked instead, on a number of occasions, about her plans to fully retire and if she had decided on a final retirement date. She became aware of speculation within the workplace about when she would retire and who might apply for the post. Ms McDonough considered this inappropriate and undermining to her position as Chief Executive.
Due to the failure to progress her request for flexible retirement, Ms McDonough commenced an internal grievance procedure and subsequently lodged proceedings claiming discrimination under the Employment Equality (Age) Regulations (NI) 2006. An internal panel upheld her grievance complaint and recommended that her request be processed immediately. She commenced flexible retirement in September 2017.
Ms McDonough said: "I want to thank the Equality Commission for supporting me in my case. It's important if people feel their rights at work are not being upheld that they know they can seek independent support and they will be listened to. Public sector workers, at whatever level they are employed in an organisation, are entitled to the same rights as anyone else.
"I believed my flexible retirement request was in line with the organisation's Human Resources policies. I was disappointed that my request was not being progressed and felt under pressure to provide a definite date for retirement. I believed that this was inappropriate and that any decision on my retirement should be mine and mine alone."
Anne McKernan, Head of Legal Services at the ECNI said: "In settling the case, the Arts Council has acknowledged and regrets the hurt and injury to feelings experienced by Roisin McDonough. It has reaffirmed its commitment to the principle of equality of opportunity in employment and will liaise with the Commission and review its policies and procedures concerning age. It will ensure that these policies and procedures relating to age are communicated to all staff and to Board members and that appropriate training is provided.
"Since the introduction of the Age Discrimination Regulation in 2006 and the abolition of the default retirement age in 2011, many people choose to work longer and many employers offer schemes such as flexible retirement. This helps our workplace retain talented and experienced members of staff for longer periods, which must be welcomed," concluded Anne McKernan.
(JG/CM)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
24 January 2024
Ards Arts Centre Announces New February Exhibitions
Ards Arts Centre has announced two new art exhibitions for February – Internal Space, a joint exhibition by Ned Jackson Smyth and Helen Bradbury, and Real Lives: The Art of Living with Dementia, a Community Exhibition by Dementia NI.
Ards Arts Centre Announces New February Exhibitions
Ards Arts Centre has announced two new art exhibitions for February – Internal Space, a joint exhibition by Ned Jackson Smyth and Helen Bradbury, and Real Lives: The Art of Living with Dementia, a Community Exhibition by Dementia NI.
01 March 2024
Latest Hospital Waiting Times Show Scale Of The Crisis
The latest hospital waiting lists show the scale of the crisis and demonstrate the need for multi-year funding, Health Minister Robin Swann has said.
Latest Hospital Waiting Times Show Scale Of The Crisis
The latest hospital waiting lists show the scale of the crisis and demonstrate the need for multi-year funding, Health Minister Robin Swann has said.
22 February 2024
Confirmed Case Of Measles Diagnosed In NI
The Public Health Agency (PHA) has confirmed that one case of measles has been diagnosed in Northern Ireland. Close contacts have been notified and all appropriate public health actions are being undertaken.
Confirmed Case Of Measles Diagnosed In NI
The Public Health Agency (PHA) has confirmed that one case of measles has been diagnosed in Northern Ireland. Close contacts have been notified and all appropriate public health actions are being undertaken.
07 February 2024
Executive To Present 'United Case For Fair And Just Settlement'
The Executive will take a united case for a fair and just settlement for public sector workers and public services to Westminster, First Minister Michelle O'Neill and deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly have said.
Executive To Present 'United Case For Fair And Just Settlement'
The Executive will take a united case for a fair and just settlement for public sector workers and public services to Westminster, First Minister Michelle O'Neill and deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly have said.
14 March 2024
Alliance Calls For Action To Protect Young People Online
The Alliance Party has called for action to help young people faced with blackmail or similar situations online.
Alliance Calls For Action To Protect Young People Online
The Alliance Party has called for action to help young people faced with blackmail or similar situations online.