Menu
09/07/2004
Human Rights Commission in Rathgael success
The Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission has been granted leave to take judicial review proceedings against the Secretary of State, challenging the decision of the Northern Ireland Office (NIO) to refuse the Commission access to Rathgael Juvenile Justice Centre.
In March 2002 the Commission published research entitled 'In Our Care', reviewing the conditions under which children and young people are detained in the criminal justice system in Northern Ireland.
The report contained some 170 recommendations aimed at transforming the care of children in custody, however, since last year the Commission has attempted to secure permission to visit Rathgael only to be refused by the NIO claiming the Commission has no right of access under its powers and that other, more appropriate bodies have the responsibility to inspect Rathgael.
Commenting on the decision, Commission Chief Executive, Paddy Sloan said: “It is very disappointing that we should have to resort to the courts to secure the cooperation of the NIO on this matter.
"The Secretary of State has been considering a Review of the Commission’s powers since March 2001, without any definitive response. It is quite unacceptable that despite Parliamentary assertion of full cooperation, a simple follow-up exercise such as is proposed should be blocked by the NIO.
"The Commission has a supportive, not inspectorate role and is very conscious of its responsibility to protect and promote the human rights of the children and young people who are currently held in custody.”
Lord Justice Weatherup granted leave for the Commission to judicially review the Secretary of State based on two key points: firstly, that the Commission has a legitimate expectation of cooperation from the Government given its previous commitment to cooperation, clearly stated to Parliament and, secondly, that the NIO has wrongly assumed that the Commission’s powers in this case may only be exercised where no other statutory provisions exist for the type of work proposed by the Commission.
'In Our Care: Promoting the Rights of Children in Custody' was published by the Commission in March 2002.
(MB)
In March 2002 the Commission published research entitled 'In Our Care', reviewing the conditions under which children and young people are detained in the criminal justice system in Northern Ireland.
The report contained some 170 recommendations aimed at transforming the care of children in custody, however, since last year the Commission has attempted to secure permission to visit Rathgael only to be refused by the NIO claiming the Commission has no right of access under its powers and that other, more appropriate bodies have the responsibility to inspect Rathgael.
Commenting on the decision, Commission Chief Executive, Paddy Sloan said: “It is very disappointing that we should have to resort to the courts to secure the cooperation of the NIO on this matter.
"The Secretary of State has been considering a Review of the Commission’s powers since March 2001, without any definitive response. It is quite unacceptable that despite Parliamentary assertion of full cooperation, a simple follow-up exercise such as is proposed should be blocked by the NIO.
"The Commission has a supportive, not inspectorate role and is very conscious of its responsibility to protect and promote the human rights of the children and young people who are currently held in custody.”
Lord Justice Weatherup granted leave for the Commission to judicially review the Secretary of State based on two key points: firstly, that the Commission has a legitimate expectation of cooperation from the Government given its previous commitment to cooperation, clearly stated to Parliament and, secondly, that the NIO has wrongly assumed that the Commission’s powers in this case may only be exercised where no other statutory provisions exist for the type of work proposed by the Commission.
'In Our Care: Promoting the Rights of Children in Custody' was published by the Commission in March 2002.
(MB)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
26 January 2024
Southern Trust Must Keep Women Udpated Amid Review – SF
Sinn Féin has called on the Southern Trust to ensure women are kept updated during the ongoing review of cervical smear tests. The party's health spokesperson, Linda Dillon, said: "The trust must ensure women affected by the cervical smear review are kept updated, including regarding any delays they are dealing with.
Southern Trust Must Keep Women Udpated Amid Review – SF
Sinn Féin has called on the Southern Trust to ensure women are kept updated during the ongoing review of cervical smear tests. The party's health spokesperson, Linda Dillon, said: "The trust must ensure women affected by the cervical smear review are kept updated, including regarding any delays they are dealing with.
27 March 2024
SDLP Calls For Urgent Restoration Of North South Ministerial Council
The SDLP has called for the urgent restoration of the North South Ministerial Council (NSMC), which it said is needed to advance all-island cooperation following the restoration of the Stormont government earlier this year.
SDLP Calls For Urgent Restoration Of North South Ministerial Council
The SDLP has called for the urgent restoration of the North South Ministerial Council (NSMC), which it said is needed to advance all-island cooperation following the restoration of the Stormont government earlier this year.
04 March 2024
New Report Highlights Current State Of NI Rivers
No single stretch of river in Northern Ireland is is "good overall health", this was the message of the Rivers Trust, in its latest 'State Of Our Rivers Report'.
New Report Highlights Current State Of NI Rivers
No single stretch of river in Northern Ireland is is "good overall health", this was the message of the Rivers Trust, in its latest 'State Of Our Rivers Report'.
08 June 2005
Queen’s to debate future of Human Rights Commissions
The future of Human Rights Commissions in the UK and Ireland will be examined at Queen's University Belfast this week. The Human Rights Centre at the Queen's School of Law, in co-operation with the Faculty of Law, University of Bristol, will hold a half-day conference in Belfast on Friday on the role of both Commissions.
Queen’s to debate future of Human Rights Commissions
The future of Human Rights Commissions in the UK and Ireland will be examined at Queen's University Belfast this week. The Human Rights Centre at the Queen's School of Law, in co-operation with the Faculty of Law, University of Bristol, will hold a half-day conference in Belfast on Friday on the role of both Commissions.
18 April 2002
Human Rights Commission critical of NIO support
In its annual statement to the UN, the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission has criticised the Northern Ireland Office for providing inadequate funding and insufficient disclosure.
Human Rights Commission critical of NIO support
In its annual statement to the UN, the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission has criticised the Northern Ireland Office for providing inadequate funding and insufficient disclosure.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherThis Evening and Tonight:Showers will gradually die out during the evening. A cold night with long clear spells leading to a touch of frost in places. Light winds. Minimum temperature 0 °C.
