John Lewis planning permission overturned

The High Court in Belfast has today overturned a decision to grant planning permission for a John Lewis store in County Antrim.

Today's decision rejects the application for the £40 million development, which had previously been given the go ahead to be built at Sprucefield, just outside Lisburn in County Antrim.

Permission had previously been granted by a the then Northern Ireland Environment Minister Lord Rooker, who agreed to allow a £200 million expansion to be added to the Sprucefield retail park, which would have included the John Lewis store, creating around 1,000 jobs.

Traders from Belfast, Lisburn and Craigavon along with Belfast City Council, went to the High Court to challenge the planning permission after the retailer was given the go-ahead in June 2005 against the advice of Planning Service officials.

After a length and complicated judgement, the High Court Judge, Mr Justice Girvan, overturned Lord Rooker's decision on the grounds that he did not follow correct procedures and added that his decision not to hold a planning inquiry into the planning application was flawed.

The judge also added that today's decision had no bearing on the John Lewis store, and continued to say that if the company were to put in a fresh planning application, which was handled properly, then it could very well be approved.

However, throughout the process, The John Lewis Partnership has insisted that it will go to Sprucefield or nowhere and that there is a limited window of opportunity within which it will open in Northern Ireland.

It is now likely that the store will open in Dublin.


Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

29 April 2010
Protest Follows Planning Service Cuts
Protest action takes place today as the Royal Town Planning Institute (RTPI) has become the latest body to criticise the NI Planning Service's bid to redeploy as many as one in three of its employees.
09 May 2002
Good planning benefits economy and the environment
The economy and the environment can both be winners if we have good planning processes the Northern Ireland Minister of Environment Dermot Nesbitt has said.
23 April 2013
Boost For Solar Energy Welcomed
Alliance South Down spokesperson, Councillor Patrick Clarke, has welcomed the announcement by the Environment Minister that schools, businesses and farm buildings will no longer need planning permission for solar panels. The change relates to micro generation equipment, including solar panels, which generate electricity or heat from sunlight.
15 December 2010
Planning Bill 'Rammed Through', Says UUP
A Bill to transfer planning powers to councils is fundamental to the development of local democracy, the NI Environment Minister, Edwin Poots said on Tuesday. However, the speed of its Assembly progress has been heavily criticised as not allowing enough time for scrutiny.
11 January 2013
Planning Restrictions Threaten John Lewis Development
New planning restrictions may have dealt a final blow to a long-running proposal to develop a John Lewis store at the Sprucefield shopping centre, despite claims from the Environment Minister they are not prejudicial to the development.