Omagh judge orders investigation into evidence

The judge at the Omagh bomb trial has today hit out at two police officers after it emerged that there had been doubt cast upon the evidence in which they supplied to the court.

Mr Justice Weir, said that the actions of Detective Sergeant Fiona Cooper and Detective Sgt Philip Marshall - now Detective Chief Inspector, in the trial of Sean Hoey, 37, had been "reprehensible" and that the “credibility of the two witnesses had been brought into serious question."

The Police Ombudsman has now been called in to investigate their actions.

Mr Justice Weir requested the investigation when ruling on a defence application to have two of the 58 charges – unrelated to the Omagh bombing – against the alleged Omagh bomber, scrapped.

The charges related to a murder conspiracy and a mortar bomb find at Altmore Forest at Dungannon, Co Tyrone, in April 2001.

Mr Justice Weir rejected the application.

He said: "I do not however accept in the course of the present case that the conduct of the police witnesses is so grave as to threaten or undermine the rule of law itself.

"Any prejudice can be dealt with within the trial process."

The accusations against the two police witnesses relate to written statements which they made and which the court heard had replaced earlier statements which had since disappeared.

Hoey's lawyer, Orlando Pownall QC, alleged the statements had been doctored to make case against Hoey appear stronger.

Sean Hoey, 37, of Molly Road, Jonesborough, County Armagh, faces 58 charges including the murders of 29 people during the Omagh bombing in 1998. He denies all the charges.


Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

08 October 2014
Police Cancel Appeal For Missing Omagh Man
Police have said they believe missing Omagh man, Shane Sharkey, has been found in the Republic of Ireland. A police appeal for help in finding the 35-year-old has been cancelled, with police saying they now believe they know where he is. No further details have been released but police thanked the public for their help.
21 September 2006
Video-link set up for trial of Omagh bomber
The families of the Omagh bomb victims will be able to follow the events of the trial of the man accused of carrying out the atrocity, by a special video-link facility which is to be set up in between Belfast Court and Omagh College.
20 December 2007
Omagh Bomb Trial Returns Not Guilty Verdict
A not guilty verdict was returned in the trial of a man accused of killing 29 people in the Omagh bombing. Sean Hoey, 38, from Jonesborough, Co Armagh was cleared on a total of 56 charges relating to the 1998 bombing. The attack, which devastated the Co Tyrone town, was carried out by the Real IRA.
17 January 2013
Omagh Bomb Man Avoids Extradition
A man held liable for the Omagh bombing will not be extradited to Lithuania to face charges of weapons smuggling. A Belfast judge said Liam Campbell is likely to be held in inhuman and degrading conditions if extradited.
25 February 2010
Omagh Bomb Suspect Acquitted
The only man jailed over the 1998 Omagh bombing was yesterday cleared following a retrial in Dublin. Colm Murphy, 57, from Co Louth, was imprisioned for 14 years in 2002 for conspiracy but won an appeal against his conviction in 2005 and was sent for a retrial in January this year at the non-jury Special Criminal Court in Dublin.