Victims Commissioner appointment not quashed

A High Court ruling has not quashed the appointment of Bertha McDougall as the Northern Ireland Interim Victims Commissioner.

However, in his ruling Lord Justice Girvan said that the appointment was "improper and politically motivated."

The decision by the High Court will see Mrs McDougall produce an annual report that will make recommendations to the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland on the issues of victims.

The production of the report, which was granted a two-month extension, is expected in January.

West Belfast woman Brenda Downes challenged Mrs Dougall's appointment in the High Court on the grounds that she did not have cross-community support in her role as Victims Commissioner.

The Northern Ireland Secretary of State welcomed the decision not to quash the appointment, and appeal against the ruling is being considered.

Mr Hain said: "Today's court ruling recognises the important work which Bertha McDougall is doing on behalf of all victims. She is due to present her report to me soon and I welcome the fact that she can complete her work.

"I appointed Mrs McDougall as Interim Victims Commissioner for one year to produce a report so that when a permanent Victims Commissioner is in place, the preparatory work for that office will already have been done.

"Today's ruling recognises the importance of the work being undertaken by Mrs McDougall and I make no apology of getting this process started because for too long the needs of victims have not been comprehensively addressed.

"Whilst I welcome the Court's refusal to quash Mrs McDougall's appointment, I am disappointed by the finding that the appointment was unlawful and I will be appealing that in the strongest possible terms."

A senior QC is also examining the case after the Attorney General was asked to investigate the case following allegations that the NI Secretary of State had misled the High Court.


Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

20 November 2006
Judge calls for inquiry into McDougall appointment
A High Court Judge has today asked for the government's appointment of interim Victims' Commissioner Bertha McDougall, 59, to be investigated by the attorney general. Lord Goldsmith is now to examine whether the court was deliberately misled by the Northern Ireland Office during the judicial review of her appointment.
09 March 2020
Man Due In Court Over Alleged Child Sex Abuse
A man is due in court this morning, Monday 09 March, over the alleged sex abuse of a child. The 31 year-old has been charged with two counts of causing or inciting a child under 13 to engage in sexual activity. The charges follow a report to police in the Lurgan area on Thursday 05 March. The suspect will appear before Lisburn Magistrates Court.
04 March 2020
22 Year-Old In Court Over August Burglary
Police have charged a 22 year-old man following a burglary in south Belfast last August. The suspect was due to appear at Belfast Magistrates Court today, Wednesday 04 March, charged with burglary with intent to steal.
13 February 2020
Suspect Due In Court Over £200k Drug Find
A 27 year-old is due in court charged with drug related offences after substances worth an estimated £200,000 were seized in Belfast.
30 January 2020
Suspect Due In Court Over L'Derry Attempted Murder
A 23 year-old man has been charged with attempted murder following an assault that left a man in serious condition in L'Derry last month. The suspect is due to appear in the city's Magistrates' Court this morning, Thursday 30 January. It comes after the serious assault in the Cornshell Fields area during the early hours of Monday 02 December.