Menu
15/08/2008
O'Loan 'Sorry' For Giving Offence
Although not renowned for controversy, the BBC's long-running radio show, Woman's Hour, has this week sparked considerable debate over remarks attributed to Dame Nuala O'Loan which have been interpreted in some quarters as a slur on NI Protestants.
Her comments on the BBC Radio Four programme have been criticised by listeners leaving comments on the BBC's Woman's Hour website.
One correspondent said: "I was deeply upset, and hurt, by Nuala O'Loan saying that Protestants in N.Ireland grew up being told that they could not trust Catholics. This was certainly not my experience nor, I'm pretty sure, would it have been the experience of the majority of our Protestant friends."
Another correspondent writes: "All I can say is that I was never aware of anyone being told that Catholics couldn't be trusted. Since hearing this being said by Nuala O'Loan... I've mentioned it to a few people locally and they've all been horrified. I'm sure it'll have caused great offence [to Protestants].
Today's Belfast News Letter reports on a 'lengthy discussion' on the matter, with Mrs O'Loan saying that she was sorry if her radio remark was deemed offensive "but I simply report what was said to me".
The former boss of the body representing NI's electricity users, and latterly, the first ever NI Policing Ombudsman's reported comments follow those of other senior figures in the Catholic community about Protestants in recent years.
In 2005, at a public meeting, Father Alec Reid compared the unionist community to Nazis.
"They [Catholics] were not treated like human beings," he said. "It was like the Nazis' treatment of the Jews."
The same year, Irish President Mary McAleese also compared Protestants to Nazis.
"They [Nazis] gave to their children an irrational hatred of Jews in the same way that people in Northern Ireland transmitted to their children an irrational hatred, for example, of Catholics, in the same way that people give to their children an outrageous and irrational hatred of those who are of different colour and all of those things," she said.
See: Decommissioning churchman criticised over 'Nazi' remark
(BMcC)
Her comments on the BBC Radio Four programme have been criticised by listeners leaving comments on the BBC's Woman's Hour website.
One correspondent said: "I was deeply upset, and hurt, by Nuala O'Loan saying that Protestants in N.Ireland grew up being told that they could not trust Catholics. This was certainly not my experience nor, I'm pretty sure, would it have been the experience of the majority of our Protestant friends."
Another correspondent writes: "All I can say is that I was never aware of anyone being told that Catholics couldn't be trusted. Since hearing this being said by Nuala O'Loan... I've mentioned it to a few people locally and they've all been horrified. I'm sure it'll have caused great offence [to Protestants].
Today's Belfast News Letter reports on a 'lengthy discussion' on the matter, with Mrs O'Loan saying that she was sorry if her radio remark was deemed offensive "but I simply report what was said to me".
The former boss of the body representing NI's electricity users, and latterly, the first ever NI Policing Ombudsman's reported comments follow those of other senior figures in the Catholic community about Protestants in recent years.
In 2005, at a public meeting, Father Alec Reid compared the unionist community to Nazis.
"They [Catholics] were not treated like human beings," he said. "It was like the Nazis' treatment of the Jews."
The same year, Irish President Mary McAleese also compared Protestants to Nazis.
"They [Nazis] gave to their children an irrational hatred of Jews in the same way that people in Northern Ireland transmitted to their children an irrational hatred, for example, of Catholics, in the same way that people give to their children an outrageous and irrational hatred of those who are of different colour and all of those things," she said.
See: Decommissioning churchman criticised over 'Nazi' remark
(BMcC)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
17 April 2024
Funding And Action Plan Needed For Children's Health Waiting Lists
Funding and an expertly researched action plan are needed to address children's health waiting lists if Northern Ireland is to avoid developing a two-tier health system. This was the message Alliance Health spokesperson Nuala McAllister MLA following the publication of a new report from the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health (RCPCH).
Funding And Action Plan Needed For Children's Health Waiting Lists
Funding and an expertly researched action plan are needed to address children's health waiting lists if Northern Ireland is to avoid developing a two-tier health system. This was the message Alliance Health spokesperson Nuala McAllister MLA following the publication of a new report from the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health (RCPCH).
20 February 2024
Belfast YMCA Champions Affordable Housing
In a strategic move to address the pressing need for affordable housing in Belfast, local charity Belfast YMCA has released a prime piece of land to the market for sale in the Stranmillis Area. Working with commercial estate agents Frazer Kidd the land in the highly coveted BT9 area is on the market for 'offers in the region of £1m'.
Belfast YMCA Champions Affordable Housing
In a strategic move to address the pressing need for affordable housing in Belfast, local charity Belfast YMCA has released a prime piece of land to the market for sale in the Stranmillis Area. Working with commercial estate agents Frazer Kidd the land in the highly coveted BT9 area is on the market for 'offers in the region of £1m'.
22 February 2024
Man Pleads Guilty To Number Of Sexual Offences Against Children
A 31-year-old man who travelled to Belfast to meet what he thought was a 13-year-old girl, has pleaded guilty to a number of sexual abuse offences against children. Anil Patel pled guilty to attempted sexual communication with a child, arranging the commission of a child sex offence and possessing extreme pornography of children.
Man Pleads Guilty To Number Of Sexual Offences Against Children
A 31-year-old man who travelled to Belfast to meet what he thought was a 13-year-old girl, has pleaded guilty to a number of sexual abuse offences against children. Anil Patel pled guilty to attempted sexual communication with a child, arranging the commission of a child sex offence and possessing extreme pornography of children.
22 February 2024
Confirmed Case Of Measles Diagnosed In NI
The Public Health Agency (PHA) has confirmed that one case of measles has been diagnosed in Northern Ireland. Close contacts have been notified and all appropriate public health actions are being undertaken.
Confirmed Case Of Measles Diagnosed In NI
The Public Health Agency (PHA) has confirmed that one case of measles has been diagnosed in Northern Ireland. Close contacts have been notified and all appropriate public health actions are being undertaken.
18 April 2024
90% Of NI Consumers Concerned About Rising Cost Of Basics
90% of consumers in Northern Ireland are concerned about the rising cost of basics, according to new research from the Consumer Council. Basics refer to the everyday living essentials such as housing, energy, food, transport and telephone/mobile and broadband costs.
90% Of NI Consumers Concerned About Rising Cost Of Basics
90% of consumers in Northern Ireland are concerned about the rising cost of basics, according to new research from the Consumer Council. Basics refer to the everyday living essentials such as housing, energy, food, transport and telephone/mobile and broadband costs.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherThis Evening and Tonight:Dry with clear skies this evening. Patchy cloud will increase at times overnight, but some clear spells too. Light winds and some patchy shallow mist or fog towards dawn. Minimum temperature 2 °C.
