Training Review Slammed: BMA

Top UK doctors are criticising the government for a scheme they said actually threatens to cut millions of pounds from junior doctor training.

The British Medical Association's (BMA) Junior Doctor Committee (JDC) has today called on the Department of Health to halt a review of funding for its training procedures.

The medics said that the review of the Multi Professional Education and Training Levy - which will decide the future of how NHS training funding is distributed - is already alarming.

The review deals with the funding of both undergraduate education and postgraduate training for all healthcare workers.

Doctors said that changes could start rolling out in a "piecemeal fashion" as early as April 2010.

The BMA's Junior Doctor Committee passed a motion at its recent meeting expressing serious and urgent concerns in the principles and assumptions currently underpinning the review.

Dr Shree Datta, Chair of the Committee, said: "We are seriously alarmed that the impact of this review has not been thought through. The idea that the NHS could press ahead with this as early as next year is simply dangerous."

Junior doctors' salaries are paid in part by their employer for the service they provide to the patients and in part by the Department of Health for their time spent training.

The review is threatening to reduce the training component of their salary which will make it more expensive for hospitals to employ junior doctors, the BMA claimed.

Dr Datta added: "Fully trained doctors don't 'grow on trees' and the Department of Health needs to be very careful that they don't end up making the training of doctors so unattractive or the funding system so unstable that hospitals no longer want to do it.

"Training is seen as a soft target, but it is crucial to maintaining high standards of patient care.

"The review is discussing how billions are being spent on the training of healthcare workers, yet the Department of Health has no idea how to measure the quality of training or what proportion of a junior doctor’s time is spent training," he continued.

"The time has come for this review to stop and for the Department of Health to listen to the serious concerns of the medical profession."

The JDC has serious and urgent concerns about the principles and assumptions currently underpinning the review of the Multi Professional Education and Training Levy (MPET) and today called for the Department of Health to make urgent changes.

They want all the information in the MPET budget available for external independent review and they want to make public all the research related to the review and state explicitly the underlying funding principles for external review and stakeholder agreement.

The BMA also wants to ensure full and meaningful engagement with all stakeholders in all stages of review and decision-making and to develop and fully validate quality metrics prior to implementation of funding changes based on Quality Metrics.

The JDC also insists that they should postpone any implementation of the review at least until these requests have been implemented.


Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

02 March 2007
Union anger at health sector pay rises
Unions have reacted angrily to the government's announcement that pay for nurses and other healthcare professions has been pegged below inflation. Nurses and other health care professionals will get 2.5%, 1.5% in April and 1% in November. General dental practitioners will get 2% but there is nothing on offer for general medical practitioners.
19 October 2004
Training budget shortfalls threatens NHS staff levels, says BMA
Shortfalls in the budget for doctors' training in England will have a "detrimental effect" on patient care and NHS staffing levels, the British Medical Association (BMA) has warned. In a briefing paper for MPs, the association called on the government to reinstate the funding to safeguard the quality of training.
21 October 2010
'Review Reinforces Commitment', Health Secretary
In line with the government's commitment to protect health spending, overall NHS spending is set to increase by 0.4% in real terms over the course of the Spending Review period. This will include a 1.3% increase in the resource budget, and a 17% decrease in capital spending.
28 July 2005
Junior doctors face ‘serious threat’ of unemployment
Unemployment has become a serious threat to junior doctors, the British Medical Association (BMA) has warned. The BMA said that intense competition of posts had left many junior doctors without jobs to go to when their contracts end next week. Many are now considering leaving the country, abandoning the profession or claiming unemployment benefit.
27 May 2011
Health Services For Vulnerable About To Improve
Health services aimed at vulnerable children and young people in the secure estate are set to improve, following changes announced today by Care Services Minister Paul Burstow. Responsibility for commissioning health services for children and young people in Secure Children’s Homes and Secure Training Centres is to pass to the NHS.