Decline In Honeybees Linked To Pesticides

It has been shown for the first time that common crop pesticides seriously harm bees by damaging their renowned ability to navigate home.

Honeybees are essential to food supplies as they pollinate a third of the food we eat but the new research strongly links the pesticides to the serious decline in their numbers in the US and UK – a drop of around 50% in the last 25 years.

Scientists found that bees consuming one pesticide suffered an 85% loss in the number of queens their nests produced, while another study showed a doubling in "disappeared" bees – those that failed to return from food foraging trips. The significance of the new work, published in Science, is that it is the first carried out in realistic, open-air conditions.

Prof David Goulson, at the University of Stirling and leader of one of the research teams said: "People had found pretty trivial effects in lab and greenhouse experiments, but we have shown they can translate into really big effects in the field. This has transformed our understanding.

"If it's only one metre from where they forage in a lab to their nest, even an unwell bee can manage that."

Prof Mickaël Henry, at INRA in Avignon, France, who led a separate research team, said: "Under the effects we saw from the pesticides, the population size would decline disastrously, and make them even more sensitive to parasites or a lack of food."

Nobody has been able to show for certain the exact cause for the decline in honeybee numbers but pesticides, the varroa mite and other parasites, and destruction of the flower-rich habitats are thought to be the key reasons.

One particular class of chemicals, neonicotinoids, have been suspended from use in Germany, Italy and France but the pesticide manufacturers and the UK government deny it cause significant problems for bees.

"The UK has a robust system for assessing risks from pesticides and all the evidence shows neonicotinoids do not pose an unacceptable risk to honeybees when products are used correctly,” A spokesperson from Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) said.

Saying the new research did not change the government's position he added. “However, we will not hesitate to act if presented with any new evidence."

Julian Little, spokesman for Bayer Cropscience, criticised Prof Goulson's study: "All studies looking at the interaction of bees and pesticides must be done in a full field situation," he said. "This study does not demonstrate that current agricultural practices damage bee colonies."

Both Bayer and Defra suggested other field studies had shown no harmful effects to bees. Goulson said: "If they have done these studies, where are they? They are not in the public domain and therefore cannot be scrutinised. That raises the question of just how good they are."


Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

28 March 2008
School's Out For Junk Food
The School Food Trust is to set in motion measures that will curb school children binging on junk food. Currently in some parts of England, pupils have a choice of more than 40 fast food shops, with many targeting children with special lunch menus.
21 September 2005
‘More pesticides’ found in school fruit
Fruit and vegetables given to children in schools contain over 25% more pesticides than those sold in shops, research has revealed.
18 April 2008
Calls For Tougher Junk Food Advertising Laws
More than eighty percent of adults believe junk food advertising can make it difficult to feed children healthy food, a new survey has claimed. Consumer watchdog Which? Found 83% of consumers surveyed wanted the government to become more involved in controlling the marketing of unhealthy food to children. In total 2,000 people were questioned.
25 October 2004
Tourists warned of risks of bringing food into the UK
The risks and controls prohibiting people bringing food into the UK from EU countries have been highlighted today as part of a public awareness campaign launched today. The current rules mean that it is illegal to bring meat and milk-based products for personal use back into the UK from outside the EU.
29 October 2003
New proposals set to curb fast-food littering
Fast-food outlets and customers will be encouraged to clean up their act under voluntary proposals published today by the government.