Human Rights Bid Fails Against Back-To-Work Schemes

A graduate has lost her attempt to challenge a government scheme which she said was similar to forced labour.

Cait Reilly, a University of Birmingham geology graduate, took a case to the High Court arguing that a government scheme under which she had to work unpaid at a Poundland store for two weeks or risk losing her benefits was a breach of human rights.

A judge rejected her assertion, saying it was "a long way from contemporary thinking" to call the scheme slavery or forced labour.

The decision means that the government is spared the prospect of having all back-to-work schemes declared invalid.

Miss Reilly, 23, and unemployed heavy goods vehicle driver Jamieson Wilson, 40, from Nottingham, were trying to get their back-to-work schemes declared unlawful under article four of the European Convention on Human Rights, which prohibits both forced labour and slavery.

The judge, Mr Justice Foskett, sitting at the High Court in London, said mistakes had been made in both their cases.

Miss Reilly had been misinformed about the Work Academy Scheme, so she did not realise that it was not mandatory.

For his part, Mr Wilson, who was on the Community Action Programme, had not been given proper notice of the scheme.

However, neither scheme breached the convention and the errors did not invalidate the Jobseeker's Allowance regulations.


Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

28 February 2006
OFT launches internet scam sweep
The Office of Fair Trading has launched an internet scam sweep and web chat in a bid to trap online scammers. Over the next three days, thousands of websites will be examined by consumer protection agencies from 21 countries, as well as over 20 Trading Standards departments within the UK.
11 February 2015
Party Leaders Clash Over HSBC Allegations
David Cameron has been described as a "dodgy prime minister surrounded by dodgy donors", by Labour leader Ed Miliband. The party leaders have clashed in the Commons over party donations. Mr Miliband criticised the Conservatives over political donors who held Swiss bank accounts with HSBC.
20 April 2004
Crime reduced by neighbourhood warden schemes
The government's neighbourhood warden scheme has been hailed as a success after pilot areas recorded a fall in overall crime rates of more than a quarter. The Neighbourhood Wardens Evaluation Report, published by an independent agency, examined progress in 84 areas and found that there was a 28% drop in crime.
27 October 2010
Over £600m Transport Funding Gets Go-Ahead
Transport Secretary Philip Hammond has given a major boost to the UK economy today by announcing the go-ahead for a further 16 road and public transport schemes. Along with the eight schemes announced by the Chancellor last week, work will now begin on a further 24 schemes as a result of the Department for Transport’s spending review settlement.
23 July 2012
Government Propose New Anti Tax Avoidance Schemes
The government have promised to name and shame wealthy people who use "aggressive" tax avoidance schemes. Just part of a government consultation on curbing tax avoidance, treasury minister David Gauke, also announced that companies offering such products could be forced to hand over details of their clients.