Police failures so serious 'other Huntleys' may be out there: Bichard

Humberside and Cambridgeshire police failings were so serious that there could potentially be others like Ian Huntley who may have slipped through the net and are now working with children and vulnerable adults, according to the man who led a report into the police's handling of events preceding the Soham murders.

The findings of Sir Michael Bichard's final report were presented today, almost six months to the day after the conviction of Ian Huntley for the murders of Jessica Chapman and Holly Wells.

Humberside police were guilty of "deeply shocking" failures and Cambridgeshire police of "serious" failures in relation to their child protection procedures, the Bichard inquiry found.

Addressing media in central London, Sir Michael Bichard said: "Having said that I have discovered errors, omissions, failures and shortcomings which are deeply shocking and which meant that, for example, there was not one single occasion in all of the contacts with Huntley - including sexual offences allegations notified to Humberside Police - when the record systems worked properly. That means that I cannot be confident that it was Huntley alone who 'slipped through the net'."

Sir Michael added there were "very serious failings" in the senior management of Humberside Police.

The current Chief Constable Mr Westwood must, he said, take personal as well as corporate responsibility for not identifying and dealing with these earlier, once he became Chief Constable in 1999.

Humberside Police exhibited: a lack of effective guidance and training; widespread ignorance of how records were created; and confusion about what was meant by weeding, reviewing and deletion, Sir Michael said.

Cambridgeshire Constabulary's mistakes included entering Huntley's date of birth incorrectly when the vetting check was made, and only checking the PNC against Huntley's alias of 'Ian Nixon'.

Cambridgeshire police made "serious errors" caused by problems in Cambridgeshire's local Criminal Records Bureau which resulted from "work pressures, poorly defined processes and inadequate training and guidance", Sir Michael said.

"But the failings in Cambridgeshire were not systemic nor corporate and the specific errors, as it happens, had only limited consequences," he added.

"The Chief Constable, Mr Lloyd has accepted that ultimately the responsibility for the errors in Cambridgeshire rested with him as the Chief Constable."

Today's report has made "urgent and long-term" recommendations for the systems designed to protect children and vulnerable adults.

Sir Michael's chief recommendations include: a registration scheme for those wishing to work with children or vulnerable adults, which employers could access; the urgent introduction of a national IT system for England and Wales to support police intelligence; and investment in the Police National Computer (PNC) to secure its medium and long-term future.

Other recommendations include a national Code of Practice issued to all police forces on record creation, review, retention, deletion and sharing, and training for head teachers and school governors to ensure interview panels reflect the importance of safeguarding children.

The Inquiry began hearings on 26 February 2004, since then it has heard evidence from sixty-four witnesses, held sixteen hearing days and received over 2,000 pages of evidence.

Sir Michael confirmed that he will reconvene his Inquiry in six months' time to review progress on recommendations.


Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

29 June 2004
Blunkett invokes High Court in top cop suspension row
The row over the future of underfire Humberside police chief David Westwood has entered the High Court, after the Home Secretary lodged papers last night asking the court to "enforce the law and grant a hearing".
25 June 2004
Blunkett threatens legal action over Westwood row
Home Secretary David Blunkett has stood by his decision to demand that Humberside Police Authority suspend Chief Constable David Westwood, and said that he may seek legal action to enforce it.
07 May 2014
'Skull Cracker' In Custody In London
Kent Police, in partnership with officers from the Metropolitan Police Service, have arrested two men in East London on suspicion of conspiracy to commit armed robbery. On 3 May, Kent Police began a search for Michael Wheatley, 55, who had failed to return to HMP Standford Hill after being released on temporary licence.
21 July 2004
'Transformation' of armed services sees 20,000 posts cut
The MoD's radical "transformation" of the armed services will mean fewer ships, fewer battalions, fewer aircraft and around 10,000 less military personnel, it has emerged today.
22 June 2004
Humberside Chief Constable intends to stay in post
The Chief Constable of Humberside police is defiantly remaining in his post after the Home Secretary today called on the Humberside Police Authority to suspend him.