12/04/2005

Labour and Lib Dems attack Tory economic policy

Labour and the Liberal Democrats have launched attacks on the Conservatives economic policy.

Speaking at a Labour press conference, Chancellor Gordon Brown described the manifesto published by the Conservatives yesterday as a " document of few words and fewer figures, a shopping list of promises based on sums that cannot and do not add up."

Mr Brown accused the Conservatives of making commitments that totalled £15 billion in additional spending, including plans to spend money on recruiting more police offices, establishing drug rehabilitation places, providing extra school places and introducing plans to link pensions to earnings.

However, the Chancellor said that the Conservatives were also "committed" to £4 billion worth of tax cuts, as well as a reduction of £8 billion in borrowing. Mr Brown said that the Conservatives were " claiming that you can cut taxes, cut borrowing and raise spending all at the same time -- exactly the same mistake John Major made in 1992 when he promised tax cuts, borrowing reductions and spending rises."

Labour today launched a detailed breakdown of the budget plans of Shadow Chancellor Oliver Letwin, which the party claimed posed "an economic risk" to Britain.

Mr Brown said: “When all plans are taken into account, he (Letwin) has a black hole of £18.9 billion in year one, £18.5 billion in year two and £14.4 billion in year three - a black hole which would require either huge spending cuts or increased borrowing, which the Bank of England would have to take into account and puts pressure on interest rates."

The Chancellor also said that of the £35 billion worth of savings identified in the Conservatives James Review, the first £21 billion had already been included in Labour's Gershon Review.

Liberal Democrat Treasury spokesperson David Laws also criticised the Conservative plans, describing them as "implausible and undeliverable". He said: "We don't believe these plans are achievable and nor do the majority of the British public."

Conservative co-Chairman Liam Fox hit back at Labour saying: "While it is flattering for Labour to spend so much time trying to find a chink in the Conservative economic case it is astonishing that, after eight years in power, they can think of no better reason for being re-elected than that they are not us."

Mr Letwin also insisted that the party's spending plans would enable a Conservative administration to cut borrowing, avoid tax rises and reduce the tax burden by £4 billion.

(KmcA)














Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

22 April 2005
Conservatives announce ‘six-point plan’ to tackle crime
The Conservatives have unveiled a ‘six-point plan’ to tackle crime if they win the next election. The plan includes proposals to ensure that criminals serve “proper sentences” and a pledge to build another 20,000 prison places. It also pledges to introduce new legislation offering better protection for householders who use force against intruders.
19 April 2005
Labour unveils ‘new ambition’ for NHS
Labour has pledged to create a healthy Britain, as Tony Blair revealed plans to create a “genuine National Health Service”. However, the row between Labour and the Conservatives on the health issue has intensified as Conservative leader Michael Howard accused Labour of ‘lying’ about the Tories' health policy.
09 March 2015
Labour Attacks Conservatives Proposed Spending Cuts
Labour has launched an attack on the Conservatives planned spending cuts. Ed Balls claims the cuts will leave Britain with the "smallest army since Oliver Cromwell's day".
09 September 2009
Conservatives Speak Out Against School Refurbishment Budget
Shadow Children's Secretary Michael Gove has spoken out against £170m of a school refurbishment budget being spent on consultants. Despite the high consultancy cost, just a handful of schools out of almost 25,000 have seen any improvements or been newly built.
12 March 2007
Government minister resigns over Trident plans
Deputy leader of the Commons Nigel Griffiths has resigned from his post in protest over the government's plans to renew the Trident nuclear weapons system. The MP for Edinburgh South, who has been an MP since 1987, resigned two days before a House of Commons vote on the issue.