ID cards bill survives Commons vote

The government’s controversial Identity Cards Bill has survived a House of Commons vote, in spite of a rebellion by some Labour backbenchers.

Folowing the close vote Tony Blair said that he was prepared to "listen to concerns" about the ID card issue.

In the Commons vote the government majority of 67, already drastically reduced following May’s General Election, was more than halved to 31, with 20 rebel Labour MPs voting against the Bill.

Former International Development Secretary, Clare Short, other ex-ministers Glenda Jackson and Kate Hoey, Diane Abbott, John McDonnell and Robert Marshall-Andrews were all among the rebels who voted against the proposals.

The ID cards Bill eventually secured a second reading by 314 to 283.

The vote followed a heated House of Commons debate.

Home Secretary Charles Clarke attacked claims, put forward in a report by the London School of Economics, that the scheme could cost up to £19.2 billion – over three times the amount estimated by the government. According to the report, this meant that ID cards could cost as much as £300. However, Mr Clarke said that new passports, containing the same biometric data, such as iris scans and fingerprints, would cost between £60-£65, with ID cards costing only around £30 more.

Yesterday, Mr Clarke said that there would be a cap on the cost of the cards, but did not state an actual figure. He also suggested that people on lower incomes might pay less for the cards.

The Home Secretary also addressed concerns over the affect the cards would have on civil liberties, stressing that no-one would be forced to show their ID cards on the street and that private companies would not be able to access the register of information contained on the cards.

However, Shadow Home Secretary David Davis accused the government of ‘chipping away’ at civil liberties, while Liberal Democrat home affairs spokesperson Mark Oaten called the cards “an identity tax” and said they would become Tony Blair’s legacy in the same way that poll tax became Margaret Thatcher’s.


Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

14 February 2006
Government wins ID Cards Bill vote
The expected backbench rebellion failed to materialise last night as the controversial ID Cards Bill was passed by 31 votes in the House of Commons. While 20 Labour MPs joined the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats in opposing the Bill, the Government victory means that the card will be issued along with passports in 2008.
25 May 2005
Government to re-introduce ID Cards Bill
The Government’s plan to introduce compulsory identity cards will be attempted for a second time following a trial of the 'biometric' ID card. Under the proposals UK citizens will be charged for the ID card on issue or renewal of a passport - this is likely to more than double in cost to £80.
14 October 2005
ID cards to cost £30
A stand-alone identity card will cost £30, Home Secretary Charles Clarke has announced. However, a combined passport and ID card is currently estimated to cost £93. Announcing the ID card cost in Parliament, Mr Clarke said: “No-one who wants to protect their identity need pay more.
25 September 2008
Foreign National ID Cards Unveiled
The design for a new controversial foreign national identity card has been unveiled today by Home Secretary Jacqui Smith. The biometric card - which contains a picture, the individual's name and date of birth, nationality and immigration status - will be issued from November by the UK Border Agency.
29 January 2009
ID Card Benefits 'Will Be Delivered Soon', Says Home Secretary
Work is underway to identify a number of areas across the UK where British nationals can be among the first to apply for an identity card, Home Secretary Jacqui Smith announced when she visited Manchester today.