04/05/2006

UK Guantanamo pair lose case

Two UK residents being detained in Britain have lost their legal challenge to force the British government to help petition the US for their freedom.

Jamil el Banna and Omar Deghayes had gone to the High Court to challenge Foreign Secretary Jack Straw's decision not to intervene on their behalf. They had argued that Mr Straw's decision was "legally unsustainable".

However, the government argued that because the men were not British nationals, they had no legal right to assistance.

Mr el Banna is a Jordanian national, who had been living in London, while Mr Deghayes was born in Libya and came to Britain in the 1980s.

Human rights lawyers acting for the men said that there was "compelling evidence" that the men had been "severely tortured" and endured "inhuman and degrading treatment" at the US detention camp in Cuba.

However, Lord Justice Latham and Mr Justice Tugendhat rejected the men's application for a judicial review.

Another man, Iraqi-born businessman Bisher al Rawi, had been part of the original appeal. Mr al Rawi, who came to Britain in 1985, is now having his case considered separately. At an earlier hearing, judges were told that circumstances in his case had made the Foreign Secretary decide to make a "specific, security-related request" to the US government.

(KMcA)

Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

12 September 2008
Justice Secretary Agrees To Vietnam Prisoner Deal
Vietnamese nationals serving prison sentences in the UK will now be able to return home to complete their sentence following an agreement signed by Justice Secretary Jack Straw today.
10 June 2003
Irish government's legal case against Sellafield gets under way
The Irish government has begun legal proceedings in The Hague today to seek the closure of the Sellafield power plant. Five international arbitrators will begin hearing the oral phase of the dispute brought against the UK by the Government of Ireland under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).
14 December 2004
Iraqi family win right to death inquiry
The family of an Iraqi civilian allegedly killed by British troops has won a legal challenge over the Government's refusal to hold a full independent inquiry into the death.
23 February 2004
Britain is filthier despite council bill hike, says Keep Britain Tidy
While the average council tax bill has soared by 60% in seven years, Britain's streets are becoming filthier, according to a report published today. The Keep Britain Tidy study has found that poorer councils who clean up at the wrong time have left 97% of streets strewn with rubbish and two-thirds of Britons are now living in grubby neighbourhoods.
12 October 2006
Legal bid fails for Guantanamo Britons
Relatives of three British men being held in Guantanamo Bay have failed in their legal bid to force the government to press for their release.