Judge quashes anti-terror control orders

A High Court judge has quashed control orders made against six men under the government's anti-terror legislation, saying that they were incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights.

The orders were made against six men, believed to be one British citizen and five Iraqis, placing them under severe restrictions.

Sitting at the High Court, Mr Justice Sullivan said that the orders were incompatible with Article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

The announcement comes just months after the same judge ruled that the Prevention of Terrorism Act was incompatible with the Convention.

In April, Mr Justice Sullivan ruled that the 2005 Prevention of Terrorism Act, under which control orders are made, was "incompatible" with the Convention because the "controlees" had not received a fair hearing.

That ruling also resulted in the overturning of the first control order to be made, which was against a British citizen who is referred to as "S".

Both cases are now expected to come before the Court of Appeal on Monday.

Control orders can be imposed on people suspected of involvement with terrorism without them standing trial.

The orders can restrict controlees to their homes and restrict their associations with other people. They can also be forced to hand in their passports and can be required to give law enforcement officers unrestricted access to their homes.

Imposed for up to 12 months at a time, the Home Secretary has the power to renew the orders indefinitely.


Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

04 February 2009
Home Secretary Welcomes Lord Carlile Report
The draft Order to renew control orders legislation was laid before Parliament by the Home Secretary Jacqui Smith. The annual report on the operation of control orders legislation by the independent reviewer Lord Carlile has also been published.
03 June 2013
UK Manufacturing Continues To Grow
The UK's manufacturing sector continues to grow, with May's records indicating the fastest growth in over a year. The latest Markit/CIPS report shows growth of production and new orders both accelerating. At 51.3 in May, up from a revised 50.
22 July 2003
Manufacturing stifled by 'relentless' downturn
The "relentless" downturn in UK manufacturing and continuing falls in orders, output and employment is crippling the industry, according to the latest CBI Quarterly Industrial Trends survey, published today.
27 January 2005
Clarke faces opposition over 'control orders'
Home Secretary Charles Clarke's proposals to implement a system of 'control orders' to deal with terror suspects, have been heavily criticised by solicitors and human rights groups. The Home Secretary revealed the new system yesterday.
24 May 2007
Reid under fire as terror suspects abscond
Home Secretary John Reid has come under fire after three terror suspects absconded while under control orders. Scotland Yard said that they were alerted when brothers Lamine and Ibrahim Adam, 26 and 20, failed to contact a monitoring company on May 21.