25/01/2007

European Court of Justice judgement could secure compensation

A judgement by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) could mean that thousands of people who lost their pensions when their employers went into liquidation have moved a step closer to securing compensation.

Under the ECJ judgement the government could be forced to pay compensation to tens of thousands of pension scheme members who lost benefits in the past when their employer became insolvent.

In its judgement, the ECJ ruled that under EU law the government had "considerable latitude" when determining the level of protection of pension benefits in the case of a company becoming insolvent.

The case has been brought by unions representing former employees at Allied Steel and Wire (ASW) and United Engineering Forgings (UEF). Both shut in 2002 with staff losing their pensions as a result.

The case has wide implications for an estimated 125,000 workers who have lost their pensions, when their companies went bust.

In a statement the ECJ said: "The court finds that the (EU) directive does not oblige the member states themselves to fund the rights to old age benefits."

It will not be up to the High Court in London to make the final ruling on the case.

The Amicus trade union, which is a party in the case, said it was "confident" of persuading the High Court in London that compensation was due.

In 2006, the government rejected a call by the Parliamentary Ombudsman for people who had lost their pensions to be compensated.

(DS/SP)

Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

06 December 2005
Court case baby makes first visit home
Severely disabled Charlotte Wyatt has been allowed home from the hospital for the first time since she was born two years ago. Charlotte’s father, Darren Wyatt, collected her from St Mary’s hospital in Portsmouth today to take her home for a brief visit with her mother, Debbie. Two members of staff from the hospital supervised the visit.
17 June 2010
CAA Appeals Over ATOL 'Breaches'
The need for all flights and accommodation deals to be included in the official Air Travel Organisers' Licensing (ATOL) arrangements have zoomed back into focus this week.
09 March 2007
Winslet wins Grazia 'weight' case
Kate Winslet has received a "substantial donation" to be given to an eating disorder charity as settlement for her High Court libel action against Grazia magazine. The magazine apologised for an article implying that Ms Winslet was being hypocritical over her stance on eating and for seeking weight loss treatment.
11 May 2011
Supreme Court Backs Irish Republican's Wrongful Imprisonment Compensation Bid
A Sinn Fein MLA and a Co Londonderry journalist have won the right to claim compensation for the time they spent in prison in the 1970s, wrongfully charged with murder. The landmark ruling by the UK Supreme Court said the test for payments to those wrongfully convicted should be redefined.
23 October 2009
Crackdown On Fine Dodgers
Six hundred of the Scotland's 'worst fine dodgers' are being targeted in a crackdown by the Scottish Court Service on those who attempt to 'avoid the ends of justice'.