16/11/2001
Soldiers allowed to give evidence by video link
The High Court in London has overturned the decision that soldiers involved in giving evidence at the Bloody Sunday tribunal should appear in person at the inquiry being held in Londonderry.
The 36 former and serving soldiers, who brought the case to the High Court in London, feared that if they were forced to travel to Derry, where the Saville Inquiry investigating the events of Bloody Sunday sits, republicans would target them.
A previous decision by inquiry chairman Lord Saville of Newdigate had ruled that the soldiers had to attend in person to give evidence. Lord Saville ruled out any question of moving to the UK to hear the evidence because the chances of restoring public confidence would be “very seriously diminished if not destroyed” if the proceedings were held elsewhere.
However, on Friday November 16 Lord Justice Rose and Mr Justice Sullivan ruled that the soldiers would instead be allowed to give evidence by video-link. The soldiers’ lawyers argued at the High Court that their security could not be guaranteed in the city where 13 civilians were shot dead by British paratroopers during a civil rights march on 30 January 1972.
In their ruling, two High Court judges said that the tribunal's conclusion that the soldiers had no reasonable fears for their safety was “erroneous and gave rise to procedural unfairness in relation to the soldier witnesses.”
Madden & Finucane, the solicitors who represent the majority of the families of the deceased and wounded said: “Our clients, whilst extremely disappointed, are not surprised given the succession of favourable rulings from the English Courts in favour of the soldiers. The willingness of these Courts to interfere in the decision-making of this distinguished international tribunal is without parallel in modern history.
“The proper place for the soldiers to give their evidence is, as the Bloody Sunday Inquiry held, the Guildhall in Derry where hundreds of civilian witnesses have already given their evidence and continue to do so.
“The families do not accept that there is a risk to the soldiers’ lives if they give evidence in Derry. It is noted that the judgment was given on the day after the Queen and Duke of Edinburgh visited Derry. Derry is thus regarded as safe enough for the British Royal Family to visit but apparently not safe enough for former British soldiers to give evidence. It is expected that the Tribunal will appeal this decision to the Court of Appeal.” (AMcE)
The 36 former and serving soldiers, who brought the case to the High Court in London, feared that if they were forced to travel to Derry, where the Saville Inquiry investigating the events of Bloody Sunday sits, republicans would target them.
A previous decision by inquiry chairman Lord Saville of Newdigate had ruled that the soldiers had to attend in person to give evidence. Lord Saville ruled out any question of moving to the UK to hear the evidence because the chances of restoring public confidence would be “very seriously diminished if not destroyed” if the proceedings were held elsewhere.
However, on Friday November 16 Lord Justice Rose and Mr Justice Sullivan ruled that the soldiers would instead be allowed to give evidence by video-link. The soldiers’ lawyers argued at the High Court that their security could not be guaranteed in the city where 13 civilians were shot dead by British paratroopers during a civil rights march on 30 January 1972.
In their ruling, two High Court judges said that the tribunal's conclusion that the soldiers had no reasonable fears for their safety was “erroneous and gave rise to procedural unfairness in relation to the soldier witnesses.”
Madden & Finucane, the solicitors who represent the majority of the families of the deceased and wounded said: “Our clients, whilst extremely disappointed, are not surprised given the succession of favourable rulings from the English Courts in favour of the soldiers. The willingness of these Courts to interfere in the decision-making of this distinguished international tribunal is without parallel in modern history.
“The proper place for the soldiers to give their evidence is, as the Bloody Sunday Inquiry held, the Guildhall in Derry where hundreds of civilian witnesses have already given their evidence and continue to do so.
“The families do not accept that there is a risk to the soldiers’ lives if they give evidence in Derry. It is noted that the judgment was given on the day after the Queen and Duke of Edinburgh visited Derry. Derry is thus regarded as safe enough for the British Royal Family to visit but apparently not safe enough for former British soldiers to give evidence. It is expected that the Tribunal will appeal this decision to the Court of Appeal.” (AMcE)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
05 March 2024
Other News In Brief
Beattie Expresses Serious Concerns Over Support For Victims Of Crime Ulster Unionist leader and Justice Spokesperson, Doug Beattie, has expressed serious concerns regarding the current state of support and communication for those who have experienced crime. Despite the commendable efforts of existing services, Mr.
Other News In Brief
Beattie Expresses Serious Concerns Over Support For Victims Of Crime Ulster Unionist leader and Justice Spokesperson, Doug Beattie, has expressed serious concerns regarding the current state of support and communication for those who have experienced crime. Despite the commendable efforts of existing services, Mr.
21 March 2024
Call For Education On Violence Against Women And Girls
The Education Minister, Paul Givan, has been challenged by the SDLP on the proposed introduction of mandatory education around violence against women and girls in schools.
Call For Education On Violence Against Women And Girls
The Education Minister, Paul Givan, has been challenged by the SDLP on the proposed introduction of mandatory education around violence against women and girls in schools.
04 March 2024
Appeal For Witnesses To L'Derry Arson Attack
L'Derry PSNI have issued an appeal for information and witnesses to a fire at a former school site in Drumahoe on Sunday, 3rd March. Police were called to the scene on Drumahoe Road shortly after 9pm.
Appeal For Witnesses To L'Derry Arson Attack
L'Derry PSNI have issued an appeal for information and witnesses to a fire at a former school site in Drumahoe on Sunday, 3rd March. Police were called to the scene on Drumahoe Road shortly after 9pm.
06 February 2024
L'Derry PSNI Respond To 234 Calls Last Weekend
Derry City & Strabane PSNI responded to a total of 234 calls between Friday, 2nd February and Monday, 5th February, including concern for safety reports, domestic assaults, anti-social behaviour and criminal damage.
L'Derry PSNI Respond To 234 Calls Last Weekend
Derry City & Strabane PSNI responded to a total of 234 calls between Friday, 2nd February and Monday, 5th February, including concern for safety reports, domestic assaults, anti-social behaviour and criminal damage.
21 March 2024
Arrests Made At Traffic Collision Following L'Derry Burglary
Police responding to a road traffic collision in L'Derry last night, Wednesday 20 March, arrested two men in connection with an earlier burglary in the area. At 23:55 last night, police received a report of a collision on Gortinure Road involving a black Audi TT. The vehicle was found abandoned in a ditch.
Arrests Made At Traffic Collision Following L'Derry Burglary
Police responding to a road traffic collision in L'Derry last night, Wednesday 20 March, arrested two men in connection with an earlier burglary in the area. At 23:55 last night, police received a report of a collision on Gortinure Road involving a black Audi TT. The vehicle was found abandoned in a ditch.