Prison Response To Collapsed Inmate 'Inadequate' - Ombudsman

The Prisoner Ombudsman for Northern Ireland has described as "inadequate" the response by staff at Maghaberry Prison to a prisoner who collapsed in his cell and subsequently died.

46-year-old David Brown died from a brain haemorrhage at an outside hospital on 15 December 2012, while in the custody of Maghaberry Prison.

The ombudsman said toxicology tests have revealed painkillers in his system, which had been prescribed to him, and that no other common drugs were detected in his system.

"When Mr Brown was discovered in an unresponsive state in his cell, the NIPS response was inadequate," Prisoner Ombudsman Tom McGonicle said. "He was left unattended for five minutes; the alarm was not immediately raised; other prisoners were not locked; and the nurse was not made aware that it was an emergency situation."

But Mr McGonicle continued: "However our clinical reviewer was not critical of his medical management in prison, and did not feel that an opportunity to achieve an earlier diagnosis existed, or that there would have been a possibility to achieve an alternative outcome for Mr Brown."

The investigation into the incident also identified four matters requiring improvement; two of which (post-incident support for staff, and record-keeping) had been previously made and accepted by the Prison Service and the South-Eastern Health and Social Care Trust.

The Northern Ireland Prison Service (NIPS) has accepted the recommendations of the report and said it has already implemented them.

Mr McGonigle, in expressing sympathy to the next of kin, said: "While some things could have been done better, a key finding of this independent investigation is that there was no possibility to achieve an alternative outcome for Mr Brown."


Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

23 February 2009
Prison Suicide Report Gets Assembly Discussion
Sinn Féin MLA's Raymond McCartney and Martina Anderson will present a motion at the Stormont Assembly today calling for the full implementations of the recommendations of the report made by the Prison Ombudsman into the death of prisoner Colin Bell in Maghaberry Prison.
29 March 2011
'Threat' Cell Note Probe Underway
A criminal inquiry has begun after a prison officer allegedly planted personal details about his governor on a note in a dissident republican suspect's cell.
11 March 2020
New Belfast-Liverpool Ferry Launches
In a week full of bad news for NI-UK connectivity, Stena Line has set out to redefine ferry travel on the Irish Sea with a new state-of-the-art ship. The biggest ferry to ever sail the Belfast to Liverpool route, the Stena Edda embarked on its maiden voyage from Merseyside to Belfast on Monday evening.
26 October 2009
Prison Arts Celebrated
Northern Ireland prisoners have won two first prizes and landed more than 29 awards in a prestigious UK-wide competition for prison arts. Artwork from Maghaberry and Hydebank Wood was among 150 original visual pieces on display at the annual Koestler Awards Exhibition which previewed at the Royal Festival Hall in London today.
13 February 2020
Ombudsman Warns Over BWV Footage As Solicitor Complains
The Police Ombudsman is warning officers to monitor their use of Body Worn Video recordings after a solicitor complained he had not been informed of filming. An officer was found to have breached guidelines while visiting a west Belfast solicitor's office in January 2019 and recording the exchange of money without informing the professional.