Police Cleared Of Deliberately Harming Man

The Police Ombudsman has thrown out a complaint that an officer deliberately inflicted pain on a man.

Investigators found no evidence to uphold a complaint in relation to an incident in Co Antrim last month, when police responded to reports that the man had caused damage to a relative's house.

The complainant accused the officers of treating him "like a lesser person" when arrested. He reported that an officer grabbed him by the shoulder after a verbal disagreement, despite having been told that his shoulder was painful from an earlier injury.

The man also accused police of deliberately inflicting pain by fitting handcuffs behind his back, rather than to his front.

Police Ombudsman investigators were therefore bound to obtain accounts from the officers involved and analyse footage from 'Body Worn Video' (BWV) cameras during the incident.

The man had been placed inside a police Land Rover and taken to hospital for assessment following the initial police callout.
News Image
Investigators found that the footage did not appear to show the complainant to be in any discomfort, and that he made no comment about the handcuffs causing him pain. Police policy allows for handcuffs to be fitted to the rear in order to minimise risk in situations where people's behaviour has been volatile.

The BWV footage also showed that when an officer placed a hand on the man's shoulder he advised that it was to stop the man falling forward while the police vehicle was turning a corner.

This happened just after the complainant's phone, which had been placed in an officer's cap for safekeeping, had slid onto the floor of the Land Rover as it went round a bend.

The man later accused officers of mishandling the phone, leading to its screen being cracked when it fell.

However, the Police Ombudsman investigator noted that the floor of the vehicle was carpeted, and that there was no evidence that the screen had not been cracked before it was given to police.

She also found that the footage showed the officers to have treated the man with respect.

The investigator concluded that there was no evidence of misconduct by any of the officers involved, and did not uphold the complaint.


Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

10 March 2020
Elderly Man Suffers Smoke Inhalation In Co Down Arson
A man aged in 90s was left in need of treatment for smoke inhalation after two arson attacks in Downpatrick. Police are probing a link between two deliberate ignitions in the Killough Walk and Vianstown Heights area of the town, less than a mile from each other, in the early hours of Tuesday morning.
27 May 2015
Two Police Officers Disciplined Over Report Of Indecent Approach To Children
Two police officers have been disciplined following a complaint about a police response to reports that a man had approached three young girls and asked them to touch him in east Belfast last year.
07 January 2016
Police Officer Given Adult Caution For Bar Assault
A police officer assaulted a man at a bar while off-duty and unlawfully accessed information on police computer systems, according to a Police Ombudsman investigation. The officer was given an adult caution after he was found to have punched a man in the face during an argument at a bar in Belfast city centre in August 2014.
04 September 2015
Police Were Justified In Using Taser - Ombudsman
Police were justified in using Taser during four incidents which involved knives, according to the Police Ombudsman. Three of the incidents involved people self-harming, and in the other, officers feared a knife would be used against them. Dr Michael Maguire found that the use of Taser had in each instance been lawful, necessary and proportionate.
13 March 2014
Police Justify Using Tasers In Five Incidents
The Police Ombudsman, Dr Michael Maguire, has found that police were justified in using Tasers during five incidents involving people armed with knives. Four involved people who were threatening to harm or kill themselves, the other involved a person who was using a knife to threaten his mother and sister.