11/11/2025

PSNI Accepts Findings OF Systemic Failings In McCartney Case

The Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) has formally acknowledged and fully accepted the findings of the Police Ombudsman's investigation into the Alexander McCartney case.

The service issued an apology, stating its thoughts are with the victims and their families, and expressing deep sorrow for the profound and lasting harm caused by McCartney's crimes.

The PSNI noted the Ombudsman's conclusion that the challenges stemmed from systemic resource pressures and capacity constraints within specialist teams at the time, rather than individual officer misconduct.

Assistant Chief Constable Davy Beck, Crime Department, stated: "We acknowledge the serious concerns raised by the Police Ombudsman and accept that, at the time, our systems and resources were not where they needed to be.

"The service simply did not have the capacity to deliver the level of responsiveness that victims and families rightly expect."

The PSNI acknowledged that the exponential rise in demand on the Child Internet Protection Team (CIPT) and Cybercrime Centre resulted in "unacceptable delays" in digital forensic analysis, investigative progression, and the management of bail conditions.
News Image
In response, the PSNI has outlined several steps taken since the time of the investigation to improve capacity and capability:

• Risk-Based Portal: The Cyber Crime Centre introduced a new submissions portal using the THRIVE risk model to help investigating officers prioritise device examinations based on increased risk factors.

• Gatekeeping Team: A new 'gatekeeping' team is being established as part of a longer-term transformation project to specifically process all submissions and identify priorities.

• New Technology: New hardware and software have been employed to significantly speed up the process of identifying indecent images of children on seized devices.

However, the PSNI stressed that the resourcing position today is "even more challenging" due to growing demand across public protection and cybercrime alongside ongoing financial constraints. The PSNI Chief Constable has maintained that sustained investment is essential to keep pace with demand and maintain public confidence.

ACC Beck concluded: "We have listened, we have learned, and we are acting... but meaningful and sustained investment in policing is key to achieving lasting positive change and ensuring we can continue to protect children effectively in the online world."

Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

11 August 2016
UUP Slams New PSNI Pilot Scheme
A new PSNI pilot scheme aiming to deal with people who leave petrol stations without paying for their fuel has been slammed by the Ulster Unionist Party (UUP). UUP MLA Jenny Palmer is calling for the new scheme, which has been introduced in Lisburn & Castlereagh and Ards & North Down, to be scrapped as soon as possible.
21 April 2015
Ambulance Workers To Wear PSNI Riot Gear
Ambulance workers in Northern Ireland are to wear PSNI riot gear while attending disturbances. The move was taken following a review of riot situations in Northern Ireland.
11 November 2025
PSNI Lacked Capacity To Manage Risk Posed By Child Sex Offender – Ombudsman
A Police Ombudsman investigation has concluded that PSNI cybercrime teams did not have the capacity or capability to effectively manage the risk posed by online child sex abuser Alexander McCartney.
05 December 2023
35 People Arrested In 17 Day Long PSNI Operation
Thirty five people have been arrested and five properties searched over a 17 day long PSNI operation into the supply and demand of illegal drugs in the city centre and across the wider south Belfast area.
17 April 2023
Man Detained After Injuring Two PSNI Officers During Arrest
Two PSNI officers have been injured as they transported a man to custody. The man, aged in his 40s, had been arrested in connection with a domestic incident in the Ennislare Road area at around 2.45am on Saturday 15 April. As officers transferred the man to custody, he became agitated and aggressive.