15/03/2006
Family wins right-to-life baby case
The parents of a seriously disabled baby have won their court battle to prevent doctors from withdrawing life-prolonging treatment from the child.
At the High Court today, Mr Justice Holman said that he did not believe that it was in the boy's best interests to withdraw treatment. He said he believed that the child, who can only be referred to as MB for legal reasons, gained enough pleasure from life to outweigh the suffering of his condition.
MB, who is 18 months old, suffers from spinal muscular atrophy, a rare degenerative disorder which leads to almost complete paralysis.
Doctors had argued that treatment should be withdrawn from MB because he had an "intolerable life".
However, the child's parents wanted him kept alive, arguing that he could recognise and respond to them. His mother told the court that MB responded to certain cartoons, such as the movies 'Shrek' and 'Finding Nemo'.
Following the ruling, the hospital trust - which also cannot be identified - issued a statement saying that the case had been extremely difficult. It said: "We will now go on to consider the detail of the ruling and how best to continue to act in MB's interests."
The family also released a statement after the ruling. Their solicitor said that they were "delighted" by the decision. He said: "The judgement given today shows recognition that MB does have quality of life and that his life is worth living. His parents feel vindicated by the judgement, which they feel proves what they have felt to be true all along."
Commenting on the ruling, Dr Vivienne Nathanson, Head of Science and Ethics at the British Medical Association, said: "Such tragic cases are, fortunately, very rare. It is clear that both parties wanted the best for MB, but differed on what was in his best interests.
"It is unusual for doctors and parents not to agree after they have spent time discussing and listening to each other's concerns.
"However, when an agreement cannot be reached, the only way forward is for the court to make a decision. We are sure Mr Justice Holman will have agonised over the decision but focused on what is right for the child."
(KMcA/GB)
At the High Court today, Mr Justice Holman said that he did not believe that it was in the boy's best interests to withdraw treatment. He said he believed that the child, who can only be referred to as MB for legal reasons, gained enough pleasure from life to outweigh the suffering of his condition.
MB, who is 18 months old, suffers from spinal muscular atrophy, a rare degenerative disorder which leads to almost complete paralysis.
Doctors had argued that treatment should be withdrawn from MB because he had an "intolerable life".
However, the child's parents wanted him kept alive, arguing that he could recognise and respond to them. His mother told the court that MB responded to certain cartoons, such as the movies 'Shrek' and 'Finding Nemo'.
Following the ruling, the hospital trust - which also cannot be identified - issued a statement saying that the case had been extremely difficult. It said: "We will now go on to consider the detail of the ruling and how best to continue to act in MB's interests."
The family also released a statement after the ruling. Their solicitor said that they were "delighted" by the decision. He said: "The judgement given today shows recognition that MB does have quality of life and that his life is worth living. His parents feel vindicated by the judgement, which they feel proves what they have felt to be true all along."
Commenting on the ruling, Dr Vivienne Nathanson, Head of Science and Ethics at the British Medical Association, said: "Such tragic cases are, fortunately, very rare. It is clear that both parties wanted the best for MB, but differed on what was in his best interests.
"It is unusual for doctors and parents not to agree after they have spent time discussing and listening to each other's concerns.
"However, when an agreement cannot be reached, the only way forward is for the court to make a decision. We are sure Mr Justice Holman will have agonised over the decision but focused on what is right for the child."
(KMcA/GB)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
02 March 2005
MPs recommend changes for child access system
A report by the Constitutional Affairs Select Committee has called for more child access cases to be dealt with through mediation, not through the court system.
MPs recommend changes for child access system
A report by the Constitutional Affairs Select Committee has called for more child access cases to be dealt with through mediation, not through the court system.
03 June 2013
US Expansion For Motherwell Aerospace Firm
MB Aerospace has announced its acquisition of US-based aero-engine component manufacturing business Delta Industries. It is thought to be a multi-million pound deal, but the Motherwell-based firm did not disclose the cost. Delta, which is based in Connecticut, reported annual sales of more than $60m (£39.5m) last year.
US Expansion For Motherwell Aerospace Firm
MB Aerospace has announced its acquisition of US-based aero-engine component manufacturing business Delta Industries. It is thought to be a multi-million pound deal, but the Motherwell-based firm did not disclose the cost. Delta, which is based in Connecticut, reported annual sales of more than $60m (£39.5m) last year.
11 December 2014
Man Found Guilty Of 1993 Claire Tiltman Murder
A 46-year-old man has been found guilty of the 1993 murder of teenager Claire Tiltman. Ms Tiltman was found dead in an alleyway in Greenhithe. She had suffered multiple stab wounds.
Man Found Guilty Of 1993 Claire Tiltman Murder
A 46-year-old man has been found guilty of the 1993 murder of teenager Claire Tiltman. Ms Tiltman was found dead in an alleyway in Greenhithe. She had suffered multiple stab wounds.
23 October 2009
Crackdown On Fine Dodgers
Six hundred of the Scotland's 'worst fine dodgers' are being targeted in a crackdown by the Scottish Court Service on those who attempt to 'avoid the ends of justice'.
Crackdown On Fine Dodgers
Six hundred of the Scotland's 'worst fine dodgers' are being targeted in a crackdown by the Scottish Court Service on those who attempt to 'avoid the ends of justice'.
07 April 2006
Man pleads guilty to toddler abduction
A man has admitted to kidnapping a three-year-old girl, driving her hundreds of miles from her home and sexually assaulting her. Craig Sweeney abducted the toddler from her home in the Rumney area of Cardiff on January 2. He then drove the child over the border into England and sexually assaulted her.
Man pleads guilty to toddler abduction
A man has admitted to kidnapping a three-year-old girl, driving her hundreds of miles from her home and sexually assaulting her. Craig Sweeney abducted the toddler from her home in the Rumney area of Cardiff on January 2. He then drove the child over the border into England and sexually assaulted her.
-




Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A sunny but frosty start for many. However cloud increases by midday with a few showers reaching the north coast, these mostly light but spreading inland this afternoon. Chilly. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A rather cloudy evening with scattered showers. Becoming drier through the night with some good clear spells developing and a patchy frost away from coasts. Minimum temperature 0 °C.
